Trump Tax Return Judge Sided Against Dems | Talking Points Memo

Congress sued the Trump Administration this week in a bid to force Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin to hand over six years of the President’s tax returns, escalating the battle for Trump’s financial information.


This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://talkingpointsmemo.com/?p=1233421

Roberts was either knowingly lying when he made his comments about there being no Obama Judges and no Trump Judges, or he’s an idiot unfit for office.

Either way, there’s your grounds for impeaching him in 2021.

17 Likes

It would make the slow-walkers happy if he did.

1 Like

He reached the decision in part because, in his view, lawmakers cannot “haul the executive branch into court claiming a dilution of Congress’s legislative authority.”

WTF??? Is he really claiming that Congress has no oversight responsibilities, nor even any abilities to oversee the actions of the Executive Branch? Is he really claiming that the Constitution does not mean what it actually says? Is he for real?

20 Likes

He’s a bought-and-paid-for GOP slave!

9 Likes

McFadden ruled that Congress did not have standing to sue and wrote that he lacked jurisdiction to preside over the dispute.

Then for his next trick he made the Bill of Rights disappear.

25 Likes

Trevor McFadden can be trusted to come up with some BS justification to allow Trump do wahtever he wants.

9 Likes

Your schtick grows tiresome.

26 Likes

And for this third act, he will hide the Conman’s tax returns.

It’s a hat trick.

14 Likes

So, if Congress can’t sue the Executive Branch in Court, and have to solve their problems between themselves, guess it’s time that Congress starts raising an Army of its own. Otherwise they’re eternally at the whim of the President whether the President will comply with their demands.

21 Likes

And if he rules for president traitor this time, he will be overturned on appeal.

12 Likes

Funny, he looks like a Thuglikan.

2 Likes

Just another RWNJ Judge who believes in the sanctity of the Constitution until it’s inconvenient.

17 Likes

Long Term:

Trump is bad for SCOTUS (and for every current Federal judge).

Dictators are above the law. Period

The problem with the GOP (and that includes judges and Congress) is that they are exceptionally good with short-term action.

Thus, a Florida underwater in 2035 or an entire judiciary under the thrall of Next Successor in the Trump Dynasty is not in their thinking at all.

An entire decade of GOP Might in the 2020s IS.

11 Likes

Do you still read his posts?

8 Likes

This is not good.

1 Like

Shows that the Courts are now corrupted beyond repair.

4 Likes

ehhh… I get bored sometimes.

5 Likes

If he doesn’t have standing to monitor a dispute between the executive and legislative branches, then who does?

11 Likes

Holmes’ famous law of judge-based outcomes.

1 Like