Discussion: MS Abortion Ban Struck Down For Being 'Unequivocally' Unconstitutional

They need to educate the men. If men refused to sleep with any woman who unwilling to produce a child from that particular encounter, abortion rates woukd plummet!

As to state legislatures, these men remain in power because the legislators chose to gerrymander.

In a lot of abortions the person who contributed the sperm by having sex with the woman is not even aware that he caused a pregnancy.

And in most of the decisions to abort where the woman is married I believe it is a joint decision.

Is it notable that every one of those other countries enjoys affordable, universal, comprehensive single-payer health care?

In Japan, women typically spend 5 days in the hospital after giving birth, for rest and recovery along with observation. It’s also a great time for bonding with the newborn. It doesn’t surprise me that they’ve got the lowest rate of maternal deaths on this short list.

1 Like

I had no idea you were this cynical.

In one stroke you’ve erased love, any possibility of a man sharing in a genuine joy and desire for children, or the scant possibility that a man may be emotionally impacted by terminating a pregnancy.

It isn’t only and ever about a man demanding a woman ā€œhost a mini-meā€¦ā€

I’ve twice been part of a decision to terminate a pregnancy. It wasn’t easy for either of us. We both had to go through a difficult emotional process before, during and after. Different for each of us, but neither journey was more or less valid than the other?

In fact, although the choice ultimately belonged to her, it wasn’t pleasant for either of us. I don’t know anyone who says ā€œI like abortionā€ or even ā€œI’m for abortionā€. All can say ā€œI’m for having the choiceā€, but it’s a choice every woman (and man) I’ve ever known tries like hell to avoid having to make. I think everyone I’ve ever known would like Unwanted Pregnancy to be solved as the singular and actual issue underlying all of this.

Of course I can’t demand a person bear OUR child if they don’t want to. But it is as often as not a two-person tango? I don’t get the final say (being as it isn’t my body that endures the entire process of pregnancy), but I should have some say? Be able to legitimately feel and express my ā€œmaleā€ feelings about the situation and the decision?

This isn’t about who gets control so much as what’s between a couple. If one wants children and the other doesn’t, they aren’t probably the best fit… that emotional journey is best shared, and if it’s at odds, then it can get unhealthy in a hurry.

I’m just stunned at how easily you could utterly delegitimize and invalidate the emotions of the 'other gender…

As a follow up to that, I want to share my own story.

I have one child, a son. He just turned 21 yesterday.

He was an unexpected, but not ā€œunwantedā€ pregnancy. We both wanted to have at least one child together. Weren’t sure about more than that. We weren’t planning to have a child for a couple of years still. But we (and I really do mean WE) ultimately decided we were both OK with having a child sooner. If either of us had still wanted to wait, we would have probably terminated the pregnancy.

We took a full two weeks to make the final decision. We had numerous loving, mutually-supportive conversations about it, about the future, e.g. comparing what if now, what if later… Those were practical, pragmatic but also emotional and often uncertain discussions. Lots of insecurity involved mixed with joyful anticipation. We didn’t decide to be parents with absolute confidence. I’m not sure anyone really does. But I can tell you that whichever way our decision had gone, there was no ā€œpresumedā€ emotional investment. We both deeply shared that investment 100%. We both knew that deciding to terminate wouldn’t be an easy one. We weren’t going to take either choice lightly.

Our biggest shared concern was that terminating could negatively impact our relationship (in small and subtle ways that aren’t easily quantified), but we were both willing to make that decision if it was ultimately the best for us.

I’m incredibly glad that in the end we decided not to terminate. He’s turned out to be a wonderful human being. We decided not to have more children, for a host of reasons. One of those (only half jokingly) being, ā€œbecause it isn’t going to get better or easier than this kidā€¦ā€ we felt that lucky, given his character and temperament.

All to say, that a man can indeed be a deeply emotional party to the entire situation. He can also be a good partner to it. This idea or notion that once a pregnancy happens, the man is relegated to an unfeeling, illegitimate satellite to whatever happens next, is a sad cynical view…

And that’s all I have to say about this… other than Kudos to the judge for seeing this ā€œabortion banā€ for what it is. An unconstitutional assault on a basic human right of self-determination.

Sorry to offend male sensibilities and I do in fact know young fathers who are as attentive to the children as their mothers are. But it is a fact men often skip out when a girlfriend or a partner gets pregnant. And one night stands where the man is promising yes, I’ll still love tomorrow? She’ll never see him again.

If I knew you better I would tell you more about my experiences which might make you understand why I’ve reached a point of cynicism, but I don’t know you so I won’t tell you these things.

I’m pretty sure we’ve all been hurt in some form or fashion by love… I guess what matters is what we do with that, how we get better? I don’t know you, and that’s OK. Our experiences may define us to a degree, but again I say, perhaps it’s our responses to them that better defines us…?

[quote=ā€œlittlegirlblue, post:67, topic:81025ā€]
But it is a fact men often skip out when a girlfriend or a partner gets pregnant. [/quote]

Which I would argue is all the more reason to focus on ā€œcuringā€ Unwanted Pregnancy rather than fighting over abortion. Men don’t tend to skip out on ā€œwanted pregnanciesā€ and women don’t tend to abort those… Solves a lot of issues, IMHO.

Maybe this is obvious, but someone expecting love the day after a ā€œone night standā€ is probably being naive.

I know the heart is is easily manipulated. Mine sure has been on occasion, and I too could tell you some stories if I knew you better. But suffice it to say it isn’t only men who are guilty of doing the heartbreaking, or skipping out the day after promising love…

There are plenty of scurrilous louses willing to take advantage of that vulnerability. Maybe there is such a thing as ā€œlove at first sightā€, but anyone expecting actual ā€œloveā€ the day after meeting and sleeping with someone isn’t being realistic… hey, but we were all young and hopeful once!

Anyway, let’s not engage ā€œthe war between the men and the womenā€ (thank you James Thurber!). Perhaps it’s better to judge individuals by the content of their character, not by the color of their… gender?

Peace.

You do mansplaining very well.

Wow, ok… enough said then.