Discussion: In 4-3 Ruling, Michigan's Top Court Puts Anti-Gerrymandering Measure On Ballot

1 Like

Good for Michigan. Bad for politicians. They really shouldn’t be allowed to select their own voters.

8 Likes

Narrator voiceover: “Now, observe as millions of dollars pour into Michigan to defeat this measure.”

4 Likes

This is truly wonderful for both Michigan and the country. I expect to see more of these ballot measures popping up, and I expect most will pass. There just aren’t a lot of great and sound arguments as to why districts shouldn’t be drawn fairly and proportionately. I suspect even a plurality of GOP voters will get on board since they wholeheartedly believe they’re the silent majority being denied their rightful representation by minorities flooding into their districts.

6 Likes

How’s the polling going?

1 Like

wow! I’m so happy about this, because I knew about the Court’s make-up. My husband and I signed the petition and crossed our fingers.

Yay! Yay! Yay! Go, Michigan!!

3 Likes

I am cautiously optimistic, It’s getting on the ballot, which is a great win, but is anyone else concerned about the commission’s “four Republicans, four Democrats, and five independents”? I’ve not run across many folks who are actually independent, but more like “it’s too embarrassing for me to admit what party I’m in, so even though I’m gonna always side with the R’s/D’s I’m just going to say I’m Independent”

Hope I’m proven wrong.

3 Likes

If the people lead the leaders will follow!

Register people to vote. We have less than 100 days to the midterm elections when we take back our country!.

There is a Federal Voter Registration form you can download and use in all 50 states and US Territories- https://vote.gov/files/federal-voter-registration_1-25-16_english.pdf. Print out a bunch and keep them with you. Register people on the spot!

If you need to help people overcome the GOP-led voter-run-around campaign help them do that. This site, https://www.aauw.org/resource/organize-a-voter-registration-drive/, has a how-to on organizing a voter registration drive. Or just sitting outside Wal Mart with a folding chair and a card table.

I have said this before, but it is worth repeating.

The republicans know they cannot win elections unless they cheat through voter purges, gerrymandering, etc.

The wealthy are terrified that we might ever have ‘one person, one vote.’ They know they will loose the power they believe they are entitled to control.

1 Like

“minorities and illegals”

fify

I’m not going to be surprised if this case doesn’t end up before the U.S. Supreme Court. What happens there is anyone’s guess, but for the moment I’m very pleased with the current result.

1 Like

Bingo. That phrase should be central to the campaign to pass this measure.

Striking a blow for true representative government.

They’ll have to manufacture a federal issue. Drawing districts is the first step in determining the manner of elections and “The times, places and manner of holding elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each state by the legislature thereof.” (Article I, Section 4)

1 Like

State Supreme Courts have final say over state constitutional issues re: elections, redistricting, etc… SCOTUS has no jurisdiction, USC specifically leaves those up to the states.

3 Likes

As a Michigander and profound cynic, I must say I’m shocked that the Court ruled this way given that it has a Republican majority. Nothing is guaranteed, but I think it has a good chance of passing.

2 Likes

The next step is to elect a new Secretary of State who will be in charge of picking the people seated on this Commission as members. The current SoS, Ruth Johnson ÂŽ, is term limited.

The Democratic candidate worth voting for in this case is Jocelyn Benson, former Dean of Wayne State University Law School. She’s an accomplished candidate to be sure. Let’s see who has the gall to throw mud at her in this election…because that’s the Rs only move left in their effort to deny fair elections in our state.

The selection process in the proposal addresses these concerns in an interesting way - the commissioners will be chosen at random from a pool of eligible applicants (who must be, among other things, registered MI voters and not professionally involved in politics). That plus the radical transparency of the process that is spelled out should keep things on the level.

Democrats have been seriously underrepresented with recent gerrymandering efforts. They’d better be fired up and ready to change that in November.

I have no doubt, however, that republicans are already working on other ways to skew elections.
They never give up.

The Michigan SOS would have no power to chose the actual members of the commission per the proposal, and is involved only in a very narrow administrative capacity.