Discussion: House GOPer: Prisoner Exchange For Bergdahl 'Dangerous'

So Mike what would you have done ?

1 Like

If Obama had done that, The GOP would be carrying peace signs and wearing love beads.

3 Likes

Yelling on occasion is OK by me as long as it doesnā€™t happen all the time. There are certainly occasions where it is merited.

1 Like

How is it that an entire day has gone by and we havenā€™t yet heard Dick Cheneyā€™s opinion? Itā€™s hard to believe he would consider this not his business. I suspect heā€™s either in surgery, or the media have decided to collectively ignore his predictable bitching (a lot to hope for I know) or the hubbub made him run back to his 2001 hideout like the frightened little rabbit he is.

3 Likes

Your mistaking the congressman with the smart Mr Rodgers.

3 Likes

The republican reaction to this seems to verify how much they hate veterans. They wouldnā€™t lift a finger to bring a POW home. I hope he didnā€™t spend his time there being waterboarded or worse.

3 Likes

Mr. Rogers would have let him rot in Afghanistan until he died unless he felt that negotiating the POWā€™s release could benefit him (Rogers) personally.

2 Likes

Letā€™s put the shoe on the other foot, Mr Rogers, shall we? What if it was YOU sitting in an Al Qaeda hell-hole for 5 years and we had an opportunity to exchange a couple of them for YOU? How long would be holding on to your sanctimonious pronouncements about how dangerous it is?

For these chickenhawks, everything is pants-shittingly dangerous. Sane people have stopped listening to their endless Chicken Little babbling.

2 Likes

Rogers has two things on his mind:

Heā€™s out of a job at the end of the year, so he less time to say inane shit and have people pretend to listen to it.

Heā€™s got to cement his record for the most appearances on a Sunday chat show by someone other than John McCain.

3 Likes

Just for the record, this is entirely involving the Taliban, not Al Qaeda, as far as Iā€™ve read, at least.

6 Likes

Next to McWar, this guy has a permanent seat on all the Sunday talk shows. Nice to know this jerk is retiring. Like others though, heā€™ll take up a different permanent space as an ex-rightwing pol, still afforded a seat on the Sunday gabfest circuit and will be a new fixture hawking for K Street or some other money-grabbing entity in DC.

1 Like

Hey, if weā€™d thrown some weapons into the deal like Reagan did, the GOP would be fine with that.

4 Likes

ā€œā€¦So many of us are concernedā€¦ā€

This is huge! While America rejoices at the return of a brave son, Republicans attack.

To our troops: we will make sure you stay captive when we have a chance to free you.

To America: we were just kidding about the war thing.

These are the same RWNJs that want this war to continue with more soldiers staying on than the 9800 that was negotiated. The war is coming to an endā€¦finally. Deal with it. POWs are returned when war is ended. Just because ā€œsenior military advisorsā€ say the 5 at Gitmo are mid-level operators doesnā€™t mean thatā€™s trueā€¦Especially if Hayden was one of the classifiers. We since learned over the years how well theyā€™ve manipulated the entire extra-legal classifications for prisoners at GITMO. I have no faith in any of those designations by the previous administration. They havenā€™t even bothered to give some of these prisoners due process, so its convenient that they can claim any fucking thing they want. The special designation the Bushies gave most detainees has been an absolute sham from day one.

3 Likes

Seeing how they were probably holding Sgt. Bergdahl hostage with guns President ReaGUN gave them ā€“ Rep. Roger should shut his mouth and let this Admin. show 'em how itā€™s done.

4 Likes

Negotiating to save a hostage is a principle America should be proud to live by.

4 Likes

This guy is the Republican CHAIRMAN of the House INTELLIGENCE Committee, yet he didnā€™t know the DIFFERENCE between AL QAEDA and the TALIBAN!?!

Or was he deliberately misrepresenting whom the US negotiated with for partisan purposes?

Who was the CNN moderator who failed to point out this important FACTUAL ERROR? Would this have happened when Ted Turner ran CNN?

2 Likes

But Reagan trading weapons for the IRAN hostages was just fine with Rep Rogers. He happens to be my congressman. I write to him about weekly and funny thing is, have never received a reply. I canā€™t wait for his radio show, because I know I will have a new congressman by then.

Ask John McCain what POW life feel like. Only idiots think POW exchange is ā€˜dangerousā€™. History shall stand testimony that such exchange took place in all wars. Did those morons ever think what is the cost of a life of a soldier who sacrificed and/or ready to sacrifice their lives for their country. Contrarily, did they ever think what message it will transmit to the US soldiers currently working in the armed forces in case exchange prospects are denied?

2 Likes

They just cannot be happy for an American family. Pathetic, arenā€™t they?

2 Likes