Discussion: Federal Judge Upholds Virginia Voter ID Law

The fix is in?

“While SB 1256 may have added a layer of inconvenience to the voting process it appears to affect all voters equally,” Hudson said.

So I guess it would be OK if Virginia mandated EVERYONE walked with a large pebble in their right shoe.
8 Likes

Since when does the plaintiff have to show intent if the law has demonstrable discriminatory affects? This standard needs to be overturned. It is absurd. I might not have intent to shoot you with the loaded gun I am showing off but if I do shoot you I am charged with at least Manslaughter. Intent is so subjective to be not provable.

4 Likes

“in most cases, complying with the law proved to be a surmountable hurdle”

This is a democracy. In a democracy, voters aren’t supposed to have to jump over hurdles. (Or through hoops.)

“While SB 1256 may have added a layer of inconvenience to the voting process it appears to affect all voters equally,”

Once again, we need to quote Anatole France: “In its majestic equality, the law forbids the rich and the poor to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets and steal loaves of bread.”

8 Likes

Wow, just another day chipping away at the franchise.

3 Likes

Another Dubya appointee. The gifts that keep on taking…

His record speaks for itself. He is a bad bad person.

"Hudson is a shareholder of Campaign Solutions, Inc., a Republican consulting firm. "

http://www.campaignsolutions.com/#about

He should have recused himself.

9 Likes

Rings. They’re called rings, not hoops!

1 Like

"Hudson is a shareholder of Campaign Solutions, Inc., a Republican consulting firm. "

WTF? How is this permissible? I’d love to know if “Campaign Solutions” has worked to advance voter ID laws, or has worked on behalf of Republicans passing such legislation.

I’d also love to see Debbie Waste of Space Schultz and the rest of the DNC make a big fucking stink about this, but I’m not holding my breath.

4 Likes

What is the next step?

1 Like

Or through rings. Or under wickets.

1 Like

Ms. Sneed, you’re my favorite non-Josh reporter on TPM, but you really should have included a graf on Hudson’s background, for some context here. The guy is a partisan hack of the first degree with a long record of bad, politically-motivated decisions with awful consequences (e.g. Ruby Ridge).

2 Likes

Appeal to the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, in Richmond.

Never mind, I just looked them up and have an idea what would happen if it winds up there.

1 Like

I was going to comment but you beat me to it. Anybody who work with that crook Ed Meese has no business being a Judge.
He practices Scalia Law (Decide what laws you do not personally like and write a legal decision so twisted you can bake it into a pretzel).

2 Likes

a Bush judge

Please appeal this racist and disenfranchised decision made by a white supremacist federal judge!

Used to be one of the most conservative circuits in the nation, but it is majority Obama/Clinton appointees now.

But, hey, not a dime’s worth of difference. Republican or Reublican Lite so why bother voting.

1 Like

The thing I saw said they were notoriously conservative. Must have been old information. So there is a chance that this can be straightened out before the election?

Panels are selected at random so there’s always a chance of drawing a panel where two or all three are Republican appointees. But the odds are favorable. And it’s not inconceivable that even a Republican might be able to conceive of experiences that are not comparable to his own and have an outbreak of integrity, like Richard Posner’s belated realization that he decided the 7th Circuit case that begat this mess wrongly.

2 Likes