Leaked SCOTUS Draft Striking Down Roe Sets Off Firestorm

No one speaks of it, but this is a religion-based policy position being enacted by states and supported by SCOTUS. Can a First Amendment argument be made against it? There is no science behind it. I am a-religious and have a PhD in a field of biological science.For me there is nothing sacred about an embryo or fetus. If the anti-choicers believe requiring vaccination, a science-based public health policy, takes away their freedom, why isn’t this an even more egregious denial of freedom?

43 Likes

What do you think they indicate? But we’re certainly in uncharted waters here.

2 Likes

They only make change when people vote!

The rest is “feelgoodism” which many assume must be just as good (it was on tv!), but of course is immaterial to the rules of law.

America learned nothing after Bush v Gore and relearned nothing once again in 2016. The results are as sad as they are predictable.

In the last few hours I’ve read several people informed in American politics and law say the opposite. Why do you not think contraceptives are next?

19 Likes

Because people like to fuck.

12 Likes

Gay Marriage will be next

11 Likes

Lol. Really? Who knew? I guess I’m really old!

11 Likes

I assure you it’s true. :smile:

11 Likes

“Meanwhile, pro-choice and anti-abortion protesters alike have flocked to the Supreme Court in wake of the bombshell leak”
Come on TPM use the correct terminology, pro-choice and anti-choice…

12 Likes
21 Likes

I hope he sticks to the line that his religious beliefs are private and he’s President of everyone.

8 Likes

Overarching …Backsliding.

45 Likes

Apology accepted.

2 Likes

He better not say anything of religion.

This is about controlling women. Mentioning religion gives the fake religionists fake legitimatacy

14 Likes

That is it! My recent ‘unified field theory’ of extreme right wing groups around the world is their emphasis on controlling female sexuality.

13 Likes

Alito’s contempt for the populace

Alito said the court can’t predict how the public might react and shouldn’t try. “We cannot allow our decisions to be affected by any extraneous influences such as concern about the public’s reaction to our work,” Alito wrote in the draft opinion, according to Politico.

20 Likes

:stuck_out_tongue:

5 Likes

It’s all about religion–religion-based beliefs being foisted on the entire country as a matter of law.

19 Likes

They’re not using the Constitution or precedent as a framework for their decisions. They’re influenced by their religious beliefs.

30 Likes

All this speculation about the motives for the leak tells you a lot about the quality of most arguments assertions you hear made in the public square. Low quality, that is to say.

18 Likes