Judge Knocks Down Michigan’s 1931 Abortion Ban, Saying That It Denies Women Of Their ‘Dignity’

A Michigan judge Wednesday struck down a state abortion ban still on the books from 1931, finding that it violates the due process and equal protection clauses of the Michigan constitution. 


This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://talkingpointsmemo.com/?p=1431309
1 Like

41 Likes

This is going to get appealed on the basis of word spacing.

42 Likes

Court of Claims Judge Elizabeth Gleicher is going to go through some things.

7 Likes

Judge Knocks Down Michigan’s 1931 Abortion Ban, Saying That It Denies Women Of Their ‘Dignity’

The decision will likely be appealed.

On the grounds that women are not allowed their own dignity.

48 Likes

Somethings need to be repeated as it really does nail the true issue and what is at stake:

“As any woman who has experienced pregnancy and delivery knows, the process is utterly transformative of every bodily function,”

“The law also controls her ability to be the mother she wants to be,” she writes. “The statute not only compels motherhood and its attendant responsibilities; it wipes away the mother’s ability to make the plans she considers most beneficial for the futures of her existing or desired children.”

How I interpret Judge Gleicher’s comments above is what is at stake is women’s rights to plan their lives like men do and otherwise be equal to men under the law.

57 Likes

Or their own lives, liberties or their own pursuit of happiness. You know, those Constitutional things.

27 Likes

Wading through all the Gloom, I gather that this judge’s decision was the desired outcome for her.

12 Likes

Michigan proud!

24 Likes

Crawling back into his abyss. Give this man a microphone every single day.

41 Likes

One step at a time, one foot in front of the other, state by state. That’s how equal rights under the law will be re-established.

22 Likes

Would get anything he/she wants every day in our house.

11 Likes

10 Likes

Something else to think about, and arising directly from these particular comments that you quoted: Can you imagine the average male judge saying these things?

This is what they meant when they said appointing women to the bench would result in an expanded perspective within the judiciary, that has wisdom and experience behind it, the equal of any others. Why diversity matters.

46 Likes

Precisely the RW strategy to eliminate equal rights.

11 Likes

Yep haha…it’s amazing. “Festival like setting”? Because showing up for a “half-assed speed-physicals for poor people day” wouldn’t be at all stigmatizing and humiliating for the patients and just screams for a carnival-esque atmosphere?

ETA: it really does highlight that these fucks just don’t see others people as human beings…fundamentally incapable of it.

42 Likes

Too nice for his own good.

6 Likes

And “here’s your cancer diagnosis, maybe move to a decent country and have that treated.”

35 Likes

Oz is a monster.

20 Likes

Maybe take over a stadium for the day. Do some colonoscopies up on diamond vision. Go nuts!

13 Likes