GOP Rep Nancy Mace Offers Faulty Reasoning To Deny DC Statehood | Talking Points Memo

Rep. Nancy Mace on Tuesday (R-SC) offered faulty reasoning for denying statehood to Washington, D.C. suggesting that its population size fell short of qualifying for a congressional district.


This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://talkingpointsmemo.com/?p=1370639
1 Like

Mace and Lindsey are grounds enough to reconsider South Carolina statehood.

30 Likes

Moscow Mitch is from a small population state and has the power to fuck up our country.
What does Mace think of Mitch?

17 Likes

It is abundantly clear that Nancy Mace failed Elementary Logic.

19 Likes

Of course if need be she would immediately forget this line of reasoning and insist that North and South Dakota be split into Northeast Dakota, Northwest Dakota, Southeast Dakota, and Southwest Dakota. It would be startling to hear one good-faith, honestly meant argument on policy from these people once a year, I swear.

28 Likes

The problem with her logic however is that two states — Wyoming and Vermont — have populations smaller than that of the District of Columbia. Ironically, Mace made the comments while standing next to House Republican Conference Chair Liz Cheney, who represents Wyoming.

What a maroon.

23 Likes

Well reading her bio on her US Representative page she’s also failed in proof reading. (yes I know I am terrible at proofing my own comments, but I’m not a public figure).

She grew up in Goose Creek, S.C. and eventually graduated from Stratford High School, but not before working at the Waffle House on College Park Road in Ladson (exit 203).

She graduated magna cum laude from The Citadel, the Military College of South Carolina, where she was the school’s first female to graduate from its Corps of Cadets in 1999. She later earned a masters degree in Mass Communication from The University of Georgia in 2004.

12 Likes

Either that or she has no idea how many people live in DC, in Vermont, and in Wyoming.

21 Likes

As well as junior high civics though many of us were exposed to these basic constitutional issues in 4th and 5th grade.

6 Likes

lol, I had no idea, either, then again I am not making any public speeches about policy. Come to think of it though, when has not knowing shit about a topic ever slowed down a GOPer.

11 Likes

If the average size is 710k people, then there will be many districts that have fewer people in them than DC does. This is just another nonsense argument where Republicans are trying to make sure Black Americans don’t have equal representation in our government.

16 Likes

Not knowing may actually work to their advantage, if it makes them look less like the liars they often are.

10 Likes

"Beneath Mace’s argument is a fear among Republicans that designating the District of Columbia as a state would help Democrats, likely affording them two additional Democratic senators. "

This is too wishy-washy. That IS the reason. Period. End of story. No other reason. Nothing else motivates them. If they were as sure that DC would vote GQP as they are that it will actually vote Dem, DC would be a state ALREADY.

23 Likes

She is a horrible person…she tries and masquerade as a ā€˜smart, bright, young conservative’ that is NOT batsht crazy and then continually comes up with garbage, excuses and lies.

15 Likes

Try this one on Nancy.
How about the fact that all other citizens except DC and Puerto Rico, have voting representatives in the House and Senate.?
All Americans deserve the same representation.

16 Likes

Another vile twit ā€œmean girlā€ who slavering GQP males voted for because she’s kinda pretty and spoke the magic talking points.

6 Likes

You have a point. Although if there’s an R behind the name, you can make a pretty good guess anyways.

4 Likes

Probably.

After all, turning (most of) DC into a state would involve some complications but these would not be insuperable.

3 Likes

That’s my impression of her as well, I must confess.

4 Likes

And when has the GQP given a shit about complications? They can’t even do shit correctly when there are NO complications. They just do what they want when they have the power to do it because they have the power to do it and can therefore have what they want, including the knowledge that they had the power to take what they wanted over any objections…especially if there were objections. After all, what’s the fun of exercising power to take what you want and glorying in the knowledge that you had such power without the cherry on top of having run roughshod over everyone who objected and who you hate for doing so in order to exercise said power to take what you wanted?

4 Likes