Discussion: Why Are Police Unions Lashing So Fiercely Out Against Their Critics?

Discussion for article #231251

As for the call for discipline of the players for their display, Crocker defended the decision.

“What’s interesting is that it’s the same kind rhetoric that’s used against us,” he said. “Why can’t a police union demand that, after what it deems as misconduct, why can’t it demand discipline?”

Did one of the NFL players kill a policeman? I must have missed that.

53 Likes

As for the call for discipline of the players for their display, Crocker defended the decision.

“What’s interesting is that it’s the same kind rhetoric that’s used against us,” he said. “Why can’t a police union demand that, after what it deems as misconduct, why can’t it demand discipline?”

Why shouldn’t the police-who are charged with protecting our Constitutional rights-be able to demand that someone exercising those rights be punished? Gee, I don’t know.

25 Likes

Has any police officer been disciplined in these recent events? Has any police officer been found to have committed misconduct?

11 Likes

Does this guy really believe that it’s misconduct to criticize police? How does he even justify that nonsense in his head? You’re not above reproach. I mean no disrespect to the police that don’t have their heads firmly up their ass, but these guys need to stop believing their own hype.

30 Likes

“Why can’t a police union demand that, after what it deems as misconduct, why can’t it demand discipline?”

Well, for starters, a) professional athletes are not agents of the government empowered to use lethal force and b) when an athlete speaks out people do not die. It is hardly equivalent when, on the one hand, an unarmed African American child lies dead and, on the other hand, some police officers get their feeling hurt. If the Police Officers’ Union cannot see the difference, that is part of the problem

57 Likes

Until we have an independent transparent system to review allegations of misconduct against policemen (and women) there will be this divide. The police federation and its spokespeople should remember who pays their salaries. Among those who do are blacks. Unfortunately too many in the force think that behaving like assholes is ok. “Serve and Protect” has become a joke.

15 Likes

If they dont want to be criticized, just dont kill people who are unarmed.

9 Likes

They are causing more harm than good with their statements and over reactions. It seems defensive to me.

Of course it is the union’s fiduciary responsibility to represent all their members. The posturing and politicizing of it is not part of that requirement, that’s choice.

I’m already seeing more calls on the right leaning sites that who are honest enough to see a problem in policing that what really needs to happen is abolish the police unions. I don’t agree with this but they are losing their natural allies.

4 Likes

“…they have become quite a bit more defensive…”

Whipping out a gun and shooting someone is not defense.

9 Likes

“Why can’t a police union demand that, after what it deems as misconduct, why can’t it demand discipline?”

The NFL players used the 1st Amendment as a way to speak out. Since when is that deemed to be misconduct?

22 Likes

The Police Union is acting like the Israel of civil servants…Any criticism of willful violence indicates only that all cops are victims, and anyone proposing reform hates cops.

13 Likes

I meant verbally. The whining about what football players are wearing, the lashing out at de Blasio, the public comments about Tamir Rice, because not doing interviews is an option as is “no comment”.

1 Like

Only in America can police kill an unarmed citizen and not only walk, but can literally be vigorously defended in public by their unions. Makes me wonder, black cops were once black boys, who were warned by their parents how to address and deal with law enforcement, are they in agreement with the bullshitry the unions are doing?

5 Likes

I can understand the reaction of the police unions. Their only function is to protect their members. Any collateral damage inflicted on the citizenry just doesn’t appear on their radar - it’s not their job.

Why these groups are being given a big, consequence-free soapbox is beyond me, however. These groups are not concerned about whether their members are right or wrong, they defend their members and no one else.

Why would anyone think their motives are ‘pure’?

Until I start seeing some pushback from within the LE community to these acts of homicide (as determined by medical examiners), if not outright murder, I have to think that all cops support this stuff. Funny how that never happens.

Until I start hearing some ‘good’ cops speak out for justice (and that’s at the root of all the protests, make no mistake), I have to assume either (1) there just aren’t any left, or (2) they have been cowed into silence by their ‘brothers’.

Doesn’t speak well for them either way…

25 Likes

The S.C. State Trooper who shot the man reaching into his vehicle for his license was fired and charged with assault and battery of a high and aggravated nature, which is a felony.

6 Likes

“What you’ve got to understand is that cops don’t like to be criticized. We have a hard job to do. … Cops are just like everybody else, especially when they think they’re doing the right thing,” he said. “But I would have to tell you, yes, they have become quite a bit more defensive.”

Neither do lawyers; pastors; doctors; journalists; businessmen; secretaries; bureaucrats; retail clerks; waiters;…

In fact, I don’t know any working group that likes to be criticized and that doesn’t think they have a hard job to do.

Suck it up. You aren’t that special.

13 Likes

Having been an EMT, I have worked with the police. Speaking with several of my old ‘cop’ friends regarding the recent events, they all have said that the Police Unions’ public criticisms against the public have made their jobs even MORE difficult.
They agree more with Richmond police Chief Chris Magnus, who stood with the protesters to be one with their community.

18 Likes

It’s funny how conservatives just love to pillory unions for protecting their members and disregarding everyone else - until it’s a police union doing it. Then it’s unquestioned.

And I don’t really expect my local police to take the lead in fighting terrorism - seems to me we’ve got a whole Department at the federal level to take care of that. How about you local guys just focus on keeping the peace?

13 Likes

“What you’ve got to understand is that cops don’t like to be criticized.”

What you’ve got to understand is that 12-year-olds with toy guns on a playground don’t like to be shot dead in two seconds. What you’ve got to understand is that people committing the heinous crime of selling loose cigarettes don’t like to be strangled to death.

23 Likes