Discussion: Watch Rep. Katie Porter Teach Ben Carson His Own Job

Would suggest those as follow-up questions for the next hearing.

2 Likes

Nope.
REO refers to Rockland Emergency Organization.
REO Speedwagon was a reference to the ambulances in Rockland IL were the band is from.

I believe it’s called an ‘I love me wall.’

2 Likes

She does brain surgery ? /snark

OK, I would’t be surprised, if she was a better brain surgeon than Ben Carson, too…

While it takes some hard work to get through med school and one probably has to memorize a bunch of stuff, most surgery has more to do with dexterity than brains.

Before someone sends a nastygram in reply: I’m by no means putting all doctors in the category of “dumbass.” My own mom was a physician who graduated med school (UC Berkeley) in the early 50s. She, of course, was expected to go into OB/GYN, but she went into orthopedics, instead. Her joy was in figuring out underlying causes of people’s physical problems and she was intuitive and resourceful in treating them. In the 70s, she was using acupuncture for some patients with chronic pain (in concert with other treatments).

There are many like her in the profession today, but unfortunately, I have run into docs who have little imagination or interest in doing more than throwing some medication at a problem and who take as gospel and guide the latest study without question of either the study or its application to the person in front of them.

/r

2 Likes

And I see TPM comments are down today…

1 Like

You do know that Dr Ben Carson was an actual brain surgeon? For real. He was. At Johns Hopkins no less where he was high up in status. Head of the department. Full professor of surgery…
It’s not public but I think he was urged to retire as others could see his loss of skills. Generally someone with the position he had does not retire in their early to mid 60’s
Loss of skills… I put it gently.

3 Likes

It does end in “Y”.

2 Likes

Can I just say… sometimes people get kicked upstairs (and out of the operating room as much as possible) because they are not very good at what they do.

1 Like

In Dr Ben’s case, as with any surgeon , they gotta have anatomy at their finger tips… literally. Carson was famous for separating twins conjoined at the head which is highest risk type surgery. These days in his position he cannot tell the difference between REO and a cookie which tells me he’s a potted plant filling a chair. And it’s disturbing. Something has gone haywire there. And it’s sad.

2 Likes

And you would be right in Ben’s case I think. But it was loss of a really high level of skill in his case that caused the early exit.
I taught med students at a large medical school (PhD …not MD). His name and rep were known.
And Katie is a real gem. I hope she has a long tenure in Congress.

Comments are on again…

1 Like

But, but…you’d actually have to be listening and not playing with your belly button lint.

2 Likes

Okay, this might be a little personal for an open forum but…

If I’d followed the advice of the first neurosurgeon and the first radiation oncologist I saw, I wouldn’t be typing this now. Nothing can be done, they told me. When I asked if someplace like X or Y may be able to treat me I was told, “I doubt it,” and then they were completely uncooperative in sending records or doing a referral for me. We ended up just writing a letter to our first choice (BIG shout out to MD Anderson in Houston) explaining our trouble with the doctors here, and asking–begging really–if we might get an appointment. That requested my scans (we overnighted them, for this was back in the day when they were not in digital file form) and a week or so later they called and said, “We certainly can help you, when would you like to set up an appointment?” They did help.

Then fast forward to about 4 years ago, I was diagnosed with cancer again. My local (useless) neurologist sent me to an even more useless neurosurgeon that told me to wait six months and see if their is any additional growth. Upon walking about it their offices, my wife’s exact quote was, “Fuck that fucking guy.” Two week later we saw another neurosurgeon in a city that was in close driving distance. This neurosurgeon’s reaction to the other surgeons “wait six months” was “He said what?” She shocked at the ‘do nothing’ advice. Since then I’ve gotten the care I need there from an amazing neuro-oncologist. Docs are always amazing when they can help you though. Those that are completely cold and indifferent to your condition? As my wife said, “Fuck this fucking guy.”

6 Likes

Finally.

1 Like

Some of us can listen and play with our belly button lint.

3 Likes

My best friend got breast cancer a few years ago. This is a really, really strong woman, who doesn’t take crap from anyone. She took her time and literally interviewed a bunch of oncologists before picking one.

She made up a list of questions, made appointments, went in with the list and if she wasn’t satisfied with the answers (she read underlying medical research even though she’s not in medicine, just damned smart), she stood up and said, nope, not you, I don’t like your answers/attitude/approach. Went through a bunch, IIRC, but found herself an excellent oncologist, doing fabulous (in spite of having the “no, you can’t relax after 5 years” kind of cancer).

Of course, this is a luxury that you can only afford if you are in an area where you have a choice in oncologists, but you certainly do NOT have to take on the first one you talk to.

4 Likes

Hey, this is Bennie we are talking about here…

Jackie sent me this link @imkmu3

https://status.talkingpointsmemo.com/

2 Likes

Yeah. It was down for quite a while a couple of days ago. Regular occurrence.

Only annoying because so many of us come here just for the comments :laughing:

Comments are now Members-Only
Join the discussion Free options available