Discussion: Tom Cotton: 'It's Going To Take A Lot Of Work' To Fix Republican Health Care Bill

1 Like

Or six years ago they could have put the health of Americans before party dogma and worked with the Democrats to create a working bipartisan health plan.

22 Likes

“It’s going to take a lot of work…”

But none of them ever offers concrete suggestions for amending it because every one of their Republican ‘principles’ will take it in the wrong direction.

15 Likes

And he has no real suggestions.

11 Likes

Looking haggard there, Tommy boy…

3 Likes

From a certain perspective, there is a bit of a gallow’s humor going on here.

The biggest problem they really have with Obamacare, is that people call it Obamacare. Which is the moniker they themselves insisted everyone call it when it was passed. So now they are in the process of slitting their throats with this disastrous bill, just to get rid of a name they came up with. They could just make a few changes to Obamacare and leave the Heritage Foundation framework in place, which is basically what folks like Cotton wanted to happen. But noo…

Its like a kid making a mistake on the title of his book report, but instead of using the pencil’s eraser to erase it and re title it, he uses the pencil to stab himself in the jugular and blot out the name with his own blood as he bleeds out.

24 Likes

Sen Cotton fails to realize that his GoP colleagues in the House can’t deliver a better product than the ACA!

So it does not matter what adjustments, you all may make to the AHCA bill, WE THE PEOPLE already KNOW that it falls short of what health coverage WE HAVE NOW THROUGH ACA!

In other words, it does not matter how they modify the TrumpRyan health care plan! WE THE PEOPLE WILL REJECT IT! FULL STOP!

6 Likes

That was very vivid.

8 Likes

A lot of Work? You can bet the Republicans will play at finding a workable plan much like they have done over the past six years…

3 Likes

In the end, they may very well just walk away from the whole debacle and go with the whole Let it crash and burn and blame Dems framework. It won’t work out for them but that will probably be their sadistic “end point.”

2 Likes

You know they could add a couple of commas, rename it Trump’s Big League Best Insurance in the World and most of their supporters would be happy. Hell, some of them already think Trump gave them their ACA coverage.

10 Likes

They did! That’s what’s so frustrating about this (well, one of many things that’s so frustrating about this).

Obama really did reach out to GOP Senators and worked with them. . . . .making the bill more conservative than what the Dems would have ideally wanted. Obama wanted a bipartisan bill–because he thought it would be stronger in the long run–which is why the bill still places so much emphasis on the individual market.

Those same GOP senators turned on him though–one minute they met with him and gave suggestions that were incorporated into the bill–and the next minute they were out in public talking about death panels.

There’s a really good interview w/ Nancy-Ann DeParle (Obama’s health czar) on last week’s PodSaveAmerica (podcast run by ex-Obama speech writer & communications director). They discuss all of this–with no small amount of frustration.

14 Likes

If the GOP would simply stop rat effing the ACA as well as expand Medicaid, it would actually work pretty well.

This is for Cotton:

6 Likes

The “blame the Dems” part of that has already left the station. They have their fingerprints all over this, precisely because Ryan insisted on this pathway right away. That’s the issue with having majorities in both Houses and the White House…its all on the GOP.

And at this point, the stakes have actually increased quite a bit within the GOP. Ryan’s political credibility within his own party is pretty much entirely on the line. And once he starts making modifications, he is pissing off a sizable chunk of his caucus…for a long time. Doesn’t matter which way he goes with the modifications, its going to cost Ryan.

And my personal guess is, Ryan is going to turn towards the Freedom Caucus. Which will ruin him in the Senate. The point being, Ryan’s career aspirations are ending completely with this bill.

So what we need to do is ensure he tenure as Speaker is over once and for all too, by winning back the House in 2018. :smiley:

10 Likes

A question that should be asked of Tom Cotton and other Republicans:

Do you believe that this nation has a moral mandate to make universal healthcare a reality?

If no, then they disagree with 60% to 70% of the American population. (1)

  • Follow up question; Why do you disagree with a supermajority of the American people? What is your moral justification for your position?

If yes, then the ACA is the Republican/conservative way to achieve this goal.

  • Follow up question; Since the approach to universal healthcare should be an iterative process, with continual efforts to improve it over time (2), how are you going to improve it? Why are you not amending it to bring back the risk corridors and adding a public option? What about lowering the Medicare age to 55? Do you have any other ideas to improve it rather than repeal it?

I doubt that any Republican would answer any of these questions.

  1. http://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2016/05/sadly-universal-health-care-probably-no-more-popular-now-its-ever-been

  2. http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp1616577#t=article

5 Likes

shorter Cotton: “My friends and I want this bill to be much much harsher.”

3 Likes

Similar to what happened in the shutdown fight. Dems agreed to a doublecheck on subsidies on the exchange. I had to file form 8962 for last 2 years. Consisted of inputting the info they just mailed me from form 1095-A.
I entered 3 numbers. Then, 11 mouse clicks on “same as previous month”.

2 Likes

The town halls put the fear of Primary Jebus in him.
Do you think for one minute if the teatrolls supported him he wouldn’t be for completely abandoning Obamacare and going “Fuck the Poors - They’re on their own”

5 Likes

Always sidestepping
ACA = The Republican plan
We can’t accept that though
Because Blackity Black and Democrats

3 Likes

If after eight years your plan still needs “a lot of work”, maybe you should allow it to be condemned. Just saying. Y’all just ain’t too good at this. Let the Dems run with it.

10 Likes