Discussion: SCOTUS Overturns Bribery Conviction Of Ex-Virginia Guv

1 Like

What was the vote?

is it ‘unanimous’ or ‘overturns’ you ask about ?

WTF? What possible reasoning could all the justices have used here? And why in the flying fuck is Don Siegelman still in jail now?

20 Likes
WASHINGTON (AP) — A unanimous Supreme Court has overturned the corruption conviction of former Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell in a ruling that makes it harder to prosecute elected officials accused of bribery.

McDonnell now edging out Gingrich in the Trump veepstakes.

5 Likes

The headline say unanimous - could all 8 justices have voted this way?

1 Like

For the same reason that nine people can continually come to 5-4 decisions while interpreting the same document - because the contents of the document mean nothing, it’s all about what agenda is being pushed.

If you read between the lines of the Constitution, IOKIYAAR is clearly stated.

2 Likes

Will look forward to hearing why this came down as “unanimous” – can only assume some really flagant mistakes were made along the line. Very puzzling.

4 Likes

Apparently

The Supreme Court on Monday made it harder to prosecute public officials for corruption, unanimously vacating the conviction of Bob McDonnell, a former governor of Virginia.

3 Likes

Laws and rules are for peasants.

2 Likes

Still a good day for America…Bob has been very publicly humiliated… which is unusual for a Republican.

Haven’t seen the decision, but I would have to surmise that it revolves around the specific actions McDonnell took to help out Williams. If he didn’t push state regulators to do something, or not do something, and didn’t try to persuade legislators to act in some way that would benefit Williams, the Court probably reasoned that he took no “official action” in exchange for the gifts.

Apparently, then, it’s OK for the governor of a state to moonlight, accepting money to shill for someone’s products.

This is good news - for Donald Trump!

7 Likes

“Bribery will get you everywhere!”

3 Likes

You would think that being revealed as a cheap little grifter would be enough to end someone’s political career. But Trump.

3 Likes

In their briefs to the Supreme Court, Mr. McDonnell’s lawyers relied on the Citizens United decision in 2010, in which the Supreme Court said that “ingratiation and access” were “not corruption.” That year, the court ruled in favor of a former Enron executive, Jeffrey K. Skilling, saying that a federal anticorruption law governing “honest services” applied only to bribes and kickbacks.

5 Likes

I am pleased to know that official bribery is now perfectly legal under federal law.

2 Likes

Trump/McDonnell '16!

I still would like to know who paid for his SCOTUS level legal team. Lawyers at that price point bill out at $400, or more, an hour. Considering that Bob has been saying for some time that he’s flat broke someone(s) laid out serious cash to get his case to the SCOTUS and to plead it.

Follow the damn money!

4 Likes

I am sorry, but that is fucking bullshit. Bribery is now perfectly legal so long as the parties are clever enough to ever so slightly conceal the connection between the bribe and the “official action.” This is a horrible day for America.

3 Likes