Discussion: Report: Dozens Of 17-Year-Olds Voted Illegally In Wisconsin Primary

And how much did WI SoS spend on voter education last year, and training for registrars?

3 Likes

I would fault the poll workers. Any investigation should probe why they failed their gate-keeping task.

4 Likes

Agreed. The poll workers are to blame for this. Those kids were just anxious to exercise their constitutional right to vote. They didn’t intend to break the law, but the GOP apparently has a problem with that concept.

2 Likes

Maybe the people in the voter registration offices, but not the actual poll workers. I’m not sure about the specifics of Wisconsin voting laws, but if they’re like NC, the poll workers just ask for name and address and verify against the voter registration. I don’t support poll workers asking for voter age or any other thing that requires voter ID or would slow down the voting process. All gatekeeping checks should be done during registration.

4 Likes

Most important thing here is that a mistaken belief about eligibility does not equal voter fraud. I’m pretty sure this will become another bogus talking point in the Trumposphere. And 60 votes, if that’s the actual number, would have no effect in Wisconsin.

2 Likes

I was somewhat heartened to see that no charges were brought because they appeared to be misinformed. Whichever campaigns sent out the incorrect information through social media last year, I hope they put a big “Check your state regulations” disclaimer in the future.

2 Likes

I guess that is what we call “minor” offenses.

3 Likes

if they’re found to be in Wisconsin illegally and voted do them send them back to Fresno?

When someone registers to vote in WI, they sign the form underneath an ‘avowal’ that they are a US citizen and are 18 years old.

More specifically the current revision (dated 8/2016) says “at least 18 years old or will be at least 18 years old at the time of the first election at which I will offer to vote”.

But note the date on that revision; that is NOT the form in use at the time these 17 year-olds would have been registering. As recently as the 5/2014 revision of the form, it read “at least 18 years old or will be at least 18 years old at the time of the next election”. It would be entirely reasonable for a new voter to think that “the next election” meant the Nov general election and not the April primary. (And it is quite common practice for municipalities to use up their old rev copies of the registration form before switching to a new rev; that is, you might very well be handed a 2014 revision - or even older - if you went somewhere to register today.)

I am both a WI poll worker and what used to be known as a “Special Registration Deputy” in WI. I have been to high schools here in Madison to help register HS kids, including during 2016. What we were instructed was that 17 year-olds who would turn 18 could fill out registration forms, that those forms would be submitted to the (Madison) city clerks office, and we were asked that if we realized it was a person who was not yet 18 to note/flag that for the people at the clerks office doing the data entry into the voter data base.

So it is possible that 1) a form went in not ‘flagged’, the clerks office employee didn’t notice the age/birthdate, and that person was entered into the data base ‘normally’, or 2) the voter data base doesn’t always properly differentiate between those not yet 18 and those who are.

As for an election day poll worker: if a 17 year old’s name was incorrectly listed on the voter roster along with all the other names, there’s nothing in the printed-out roster that would indicate the voter’s age. “Voter ID” was in effect for the April 2016 election (the first (?) "big’ election where it was in effect), so I guess a pollworker might have noticed a too-early birthdate when looking at the person’s ID. But that’s expecting an AWFUL lot of the pollworker. The problem would be that the name got on the printed list for the April election in the first place.

What I would want to know is if the 17 year old voters voted early/absentee (which, again, for the April 2016 primary was controlled at the local clerks office), or if they “same-day” registered at the polls. ‘Same-day registration’ is the only case where the poll worker would be to blame; the poll worker should have realized that they had a 17 year old wanting to register and vote on the day of the April promary.

9 Likes

Why! Deport them to Minnesota, I say!

Of course, the other reaction might be:

14 or fight!

Pun-groaning here…

ID required. How does a 17 yr old even get registered, let alone vote? WTF’nF?
Point to consider most were rural counties. Jus’ say’n.

Some states not only allow 17 year olds to register in anticipation of an upcoming election by which they will have turned 18 (as Wisconsin does) but also allow 17 year olds to vote in the primaries leading up to general elections for which they will have turned 18 (though Wisconsin does not).

3 Likes

60 down, 2,999,940 bad hombres to go. At this rate we should have them all caught in just under 7000 years. Oh wait - I left off Steve Bannon. 61 down.

6 Likes

The rules differ from state to state, but it sounds like in WI, if you will be 18 by the general election, you can “pre-register,” with the expectation that you will only be officially registered when you turn 18. It seems these registrations weren’t flagged as “not-yet-eligible” for the April primary.

I can understand the voters’ confusion. If they will be eligible by the time of the general election, how is it fair that they don’t get a say in the primary election that selects the candidates for the the general? If there were consistent rules across all the states, then there wouldn’t be issues like this, but, no, we must maintain our federation of uniquely “independent” states, come hell or high water. Even when a consistent standard would make it easier for all voters to exercise their right to vote.

4 Likes

Sounds like an honest misunderstanding that should have been caught at the local polling place.

1 Like

So now we know that there was truth to all of those allegations of voter fraud. Shocking!!!

1 Like

good to know that people are actually going to the schools to register the young people

1 Like

You have to get permission from the schools of course, but at least here in Madison, the schools allow groups like the League of Women Voters, etc to come in over lunch, etc.

1 Like