Discussion: NYTMag's Big Ethical Question Goes Super Viral: Would You Kill Baby Hitler?

I was wondering when someone would introduce Mel Brooks into the conversation. Good on you.

1 Like

No, no, no! That’s entirely the wrong approach!

What you do is go back in time and grab the priest who saved Hitler from drowning as a child by the robe, and tell him to just let nature take it’s course. More natural, and you won’t have the trauma of killing a baby to live with, But that just means that eventually we’ll have to deal with Ernst Rhom, or some other NAZI thug who might be (shudder) even crazier and more homicidal than Hitler.

4 Likes

The “pro-life” crowd has zero problem killing Baby Hitler.

They support legislation, however, to protect Zygote Hitler, Blastocyst Hitler, and Embryo Hitler.

13 Likes

This is a great idea as it creates an unlimited number of opportunities. Try, try again; kill, baby, kill.

1 Like

Well look at the districts they’re from.

Chairman Trey Gowdy
South Carolina 4th
Typical voter:

Susan Brooks
Indiana 5th
Typical Voter

Jim Jordan
Ohio 5th
Typical Voter

Mike Pompeo
Kansas 4th
Typical Voter

Martha Roby
Alabama 2nd
Typical Voter

Peter Roskam
Illinois 12th
Typical voter

6 Likes

Grownup Hitler would have killed me, and actually did kill some distant relatives. Makes the question much easier to answer.

7 Likes

Nailed it.

3 Likes

I have to agree. If it hadn’t been Hitler, it would have been someone else. The conditions were ripe for the rise of those people.

Then I look at the current crop of conservative republicans and their followers. Not a happy view.

4 Likes

Isn’t Justin Bieber Teen Hitler?

1 Like

christ… wtf is going on at the times… yesterday the twitter machine blew up when one of their political reporters, michael barbaro, revealed he didn’t know how cspan worked:

CSPAN screen encouraging Democrats to call one phone number and Republicans to call another to react to this hearing is…telling

https://twitter.com/mikiebarb/status/657290084341960704?ref_src=twsrc^tfw
.

5 Likes

If you’re going back in time anyway, don’t kill “baby Hitler” just get the little fu*ker better art teachers.

4 Likes

What if:

Instead of killing “Baby” Hitler :anguished:

you rewrote the Treaty of Versailles

using the time machine you have?!

.
Just a suggestion

16 Likes

Unfortunately, I think that Hitler’s evil was pretty much perfectly ordinary. Virulent antisemitism and territorial chauvinism were rife in German culture. And there was a lot of resentment in Germany related to the terms of the Versailles treaty and the economic situation. The situation was ripe for the rise of a dictator.

I think that may be true to some extent, but it still required Hitler in particular the get the exact outcome we did. All those factors were present in other countries as well but while fascist dictators came to power in Spain, Portugal, Italy, Hungary, etc., they didn’t initiate genocides. Antisemitism was embedded in German culture but it was much more deeply inflamed by the Nazis themselves. If Hitler had been out of the picture I think Germany would have ended up with someone more like Mussolini, and there may well have still been a war but it would have been a very different one without a Holocaust.

4 Likes

Well, the thing is, events only happen once. FWIW, as someone pointed out on Twitter, someone already wrote a story about this, in which the person kills baby Hitler and the grieving parents adopt another child - who grows up to be the actual Hitler.

2 Likes

Wait a friggin’ minute! Shouldn’t you go back and murderize’ the Grossmufti Haj Amin al-Husseini ? Bibi told the world just the other day that al-Husseini convinced Adolph to exterminate the Jews! So…al-Husseini was the idea man; Der Führer vaz’ “just following orders.”

See…you were gonna’ kill the wrong baby! Tsk, tsk, tsk!

(*Oh, and before the ‘real’ history lesson, let me just say that I know the ‘real’ history.)

2 Likes

Well what about Baby Tojo? How come HE gets a pass? Remember what happened when HE grew up?

4 Likes

Nanking votes: Yes

4 Likes

If you can go back in time and stand before the baby Hitler, with perfect knowledge of baby Hitler’s future, what you’re doing is being a god. And human beings aren’t gods and shouldn’t ever act or think like gods. Unfortunately, the effect of so many dumb movies and TV shows is to make a lot of people think they can act and think like gods. The viewpoint of most movies is in fact a divine viewpoint and I believe it does infect our thinking.

You see that with people who think the government has a right to torture terrorists and even suspected terrorists. They think everything is known, just like in a TV show or a movie. So of course they think ‘moral clarity’ demands that we torture to prevent terrorist attacks. But in fact no such thing as ‘moral clarity’ ever really exists in real life, simply because we are such limited and non divine beings.

7 Likes

No way man…you’d get more money from the researchers for his parts if he’s still kickin…

3 Likes

Way to trivialize the Holocaust and the 40 million people this fucker’s war killed.

Stay classy and relevant NY Times.

6 Likes