Discussion: NYC Mayor De Blasio Urges: Don't Resist Arrest

Discussion for article #226401

No, Mr. Mayor, cops shouldn’t menace citizens when they are in police custody.

5 Likes

You. Are. Not. Helping.

6 Likes

Don’t conflate the issue, Mr. Mayor.

It’s not as if the words in his throat were what kept Eric Garner from breathing.

6 Likes

How does one argue your case in court when only 3% of those charged ever go to trial while the rest are bullied into taking a plea bargain under threat of a more serious charge?

5 Likes

Quite frankly, I have to agree with him.

Resisting arrest is MOST likely to get you killed and then the police officer will say that you were ā€˜aggressive’ towards him/her and so warranted the need to be annihilated.

Way to be out of touch, Bill…

4 Likes

Well, yes, but there is a difference between resisting arrest and being charged with resisting arrest. Sometimes police deliberately push or abuse people to get them to react in self-defense so that they can charge them with resisting arrest.

As for Eric Garner, I think he was partly reacting out of frustration with being continually harassed by police. And in any case, choke holds are illegal. Whatever Eric Garner was doing did not justify choking him to death.

7 Likes

Realistically, yes, don’t resist arrest.

But, you only are ā€œobligatedā€ to submit to an arrest if the police has reasonable cause. Some rogue police officer who tries to seize me when there is no cause, just because s/he wants to punish me has no ā€œrightā€ to do so.

If I’m charged for resisting, I have a defense in such a case.

3 Likes

Does anybody know how often the police kill unarmed whites in the US? I’ve been looking for that but I haven’t been able to find it. Perhaps I don’t know the right question to ask Google.

It’s always the same…as soon as you get elected, you realize who your real master is and you turn your back on your constituents. Same thing happened to Jean Quan in Oakland during the Occupy days.

2 Likes

The problem is once it comes to the point where they are menacing innocent citizens, it should be clear they aren’t going to stop if you decide to fight back or run away.

Sad but he has a point.

Of course, if he were thinking the actual statement would be:

ā€œDon’t do anything that an officer can decide, at his whim, to consider resisting arrestā€

3 Likes

I’m sorry, but as a black guy, I don’t trust that while being in police custody I will be treated as a human being. I use to not think this way, even a year ago, but I’ve just read too much to think anything but now.

2 Likes

The man has dark-complected kids. Regardless of morality/legality of the situation, I think his advice (sadly) is couched in pragmatic considerations about trying to minimize police-on-civilian violence.

I must have misread the headline- isn’t that the advice republican politicians give to rape victims? ā€˜Don’t resist…’

1 Like

You don’t have to be aggressive - look at the reporters in Ferguson - they politely asked which door to exit and were slammed into a soda machine. Whatever you do, especially if you have skin that isn’t lily white, if the cops want to hurt you, they will hurt you.

1 Like

ā€œif the police has reasonable cause.ā€

I think it’s reasonable doubt which doesn’t equal arrest but probable cause can quickly lead to an arrest. What’s amazing in determining results of a confrontation is a cop’s attitude. Too often cops show little to no respect and in so doing raise the possibility of a confrontation when it wasn’t even considered initially.

There is a difference between ā€œresistingā€ and being killed, you asswipe.

Sorry, but resisting arrest has long been a blanket accusation used by police. Simply asking a police officer why you are being questioned can and is described as resisting arrest.

When police officers are routinely prosecuted for wrongful arrests, then we can have this discussion. Until then, not so much.

Hell, most defense attorneys will tell you to drop it and just be glad that the charges against you were dropped. That’s the system looking after itself.

None of which comes close to excusing the use of deadly force to against a person, suspect or not. We provide them with ample non lethal means to detain people of interest.