Discussion: Muslim Student Says Yearbook ID'd Her As 'Isis Phillips'

I’d still sue. Trump does it all the time. It gets everyone’s attention.

But in this case, we all know this was an intentional action to defame someone. Why not make life miserable for whomever made the bigoted decision…and everyone else who knew but didn’t say anything? Some of them might not get into the college they wanted or lose their scholarships.

Bigots have to learn that bad decisions will have consequences. If we start when they are young, maybe they wouldn’t end up being a pig like Trump by the time they are fully grown?

4 Likes

But, but, but the one who did this will lose their perfect attendance cert if we suspend them. Then their daddy is a politician. We’ll punish someone you can bet on that. How about the student who complained.

1 Like

I think she has a case, because the student next to her is identified as Build that Wall Rodriguez.

4 Likes

Next she ought to sue TPM for the stupid stock photo they are purporting to be about her.

7 Likes

The school obviously has diversity issues.
3 Likes

I googled the name Isis and not surprisingly it has fallen from baby name popularity in the last few years. These days with all the auto check it should be easy to avoid accidents like this, but seems like it makes folks quite lazy to really check things. I see errors in books all the time these days that look like spell check errors or auto-fix errors. In the only English class I had to take as a engineering major, I had to read my essays backwards and check any word I had any doubt about in order not to fail by having more than 5 misspelled words. Reading it forward it was too easy to see what I wanted and not what I wrote.

4 Likes

Color me skeptical, but I’m not ready to jump on the “obviously this was an anti-Muslim attack” bandwagon. I was misidentified as someone else in my own yearbook multiple years in a row. The image in question doesn’t look like her stock photo in the grade lineup, but rather a candid from another section of the yearbook–those sections are pretty notorious for misidentifications because the kids putting together the yearbook often don’t know everyone in the school. If there is another student named Isis Phillips, and there is a passing resemblance between the two girls, I don’t think jumping on the yearbook team is productive at this point. More information is definitely needed here.

-Case

3 Likes

She says the school reached out and told her it was a ‘typo,’ but she adds “I beg to differ.”

I gotta go with the school here; I think a typo is likely. Try typing “Bayan.” You’ll find that you actually type “Isis” 9 times out of 10.

3 Likes

Yeah, but on the next page is someone named “Some, I Assume, Are Good People” Lopez.

4 Likes

In 1978 I was playing varsity football for an all boy Catholic school in Orange County. We went to the CIF playoffs and played Chaffey High School in I think it was the second round… As we walked through the parking lot, we had to walk through a large group of students who had assembled to welcome us. They yelled “Faggot”, Homo" as well as a host of Anti-Catholic remarks targeting Priests, Nuns, as well as the Pope.

Upon our exit after the game, our bus was attacked and pelted with rocks, shattering the windows.

I guess getting beat (28-14) by a bunch of “faggots” was tough to take.

The main employer at the time was Kaiser Aluminum. This area, Rancho Cucamonga, used to be basically like Youngstown, Ohio. Very white and Blue Collar.

It appears times have changed somewhat, they have moved on from Catholics and Gays to Muslims.

1 Like

So this past year your pre-season money was on the Philadelphia 76ers taking the title I guess.

So the reissue will have her name as “Isil Phillips?”

My money is on not rushing to judgement based on a single personal account of something, when none of the basic fact-finding that could be done has even been attempted.

Here is my first suspect for the so-called typo:

But not all students are showing her support. Trevor Santellan, who worked on the yearbook, told the New York Daily News in a Twitter message that he thinks Zehlif’s reaction is “out of proportion.” He said on a campus of 3,200 students, there will be “imperfections” during production.

“If anything, she’s being racist against herself because she misinterpreted it and not us,” Santellan said. “Because we thought of it as a beautiful name that parents gave to a kid. She obviously didn’t.”

1 Like

It’s a longstanding proofreading practice.
As a typesetter in the 80s-- we used this method.
Also learned that if you were made to proofread your own typeset copy that resulted in legal action?
You could not be held personally liable.

jw1

1 Like

No so fast.
Leicester City won the Barclays Premier League this season with preseason odds at 5000-to-1.
Only the sixth different team to win the league title in 38 years.

jw1

Yes it has. Multiple news outlets (Google is a wonderful thing) have published multiple accounts of staff, students and yearbook staff providing statements and versions of what they know. Several accounts acknowledge an “Isis Phillips” was a student at the school for some time, but that she had transferred, was no longer a student, and wasn’t pictured in the yearbook, putting further doubt about a transposition of names. And of all the students in the school, the one that was labeled “Isis”, an Isis no longer there or in attendance, this young lady was tagged as being her? Yeah, TOTAL coincidence…

1 Like

I’m no attorney, and I welcome correction from our resident lawyers, but what Bayan Zehlif should do is
sue the fuck out of the school and the district.

We had to read a short story before class and then write an essay about the story in class. I think I failed the first few assigned due to “major” errors, spelling being the my most common major error. I’d probably have never passed if not for the backwards reading and if the slightest doubt, checking it. NC State didn’t offer any English major at the time and engineers always said English 101 was the English departments revenge for that on engineers!

1 Like