I have to say, I thought Kimmel did a pretty damned impressive job here of cutting through some of the smoke and mirrors. Better than most actual “journalists.” I’m sure some folks would have preferred to see him go even more hard-core in his criticism and to take an openly hostile tone toward some of the bullshit Cassidy was shoveling. But I tend to think that would have been less effective with the broader audience, and that Kimmel’s respectful-but-assertive tone here was calibrated just about perfectly. He didn’t look like someone trying to score points, but he did look like someone determined to get straight answers.
The best part was at the very end, where Kimmel basically said that if politicians are going to refer to a “Jimmy Kimmel Test,” then, as Jimmy Kimmel, he’s going to insist that the Jimmy Kimmel Test is that “no family is denied medical care, emergency or otherwise, because they can’t afford it” – not just that kids with birth defects like his son are covered.
He was very polite and diplomatic about it, but that was the message – if you’re gonna use my name, the standard is universal coverage, health care as a right. This was a masterful shifting of the goalposts (to their rightful location in the end zone)
Cassidy had no way to really escape that. He bobbed and weaved, saying “hey man, you’re on the right track, but we gotta be able to pay for it,” and went back into his schtick about middle class families who can’t afford their premiums (which is a legitimate issue, but not in any logical way is it an excuse for failing the “Kimmel Test”).
It was a reasonably clever attempt to evade the issue, and one that would probably have worked with plenty of journalists. And to be fair, most journalists don’t have the star power that Kimmel has, or the perception of personal moral authority on this issue that Kimmel has by virtue of his son’s situation, and that he earned by raising this issue in such a powerful, personal way. Nor do most journalists have a studio audience cheering them on as they ask the questions.
But Kimmel does have those advantages, he knows it, and he didn’t waste them. As it turned out, Cassidy’s attempt to duck failed, in fact he walked right into the coup de grace:
Kimmel: “I can think of a way to pay for it – don’t give a huge tax cut to millionaires like me.”
Cassidy’s helpless foolish grin as he realizes he’s just been rhetorically decapitated in front of an audience of millions is just priceless.