Discussion: Israel's Supreme Court Overturns Deportation Of Detained US Student

1 Like

God bless the Isreali Supreme Court. As I get more and more angry as a member of tribe about what Nutiyahoo and his band of crazy Russians and biggots are doing to turn Isreal from a democracy into a nationalist state, it is nice to have the Supreme Court around to remind us about what was - and should be - different about Isreal compaired to the Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Syria’s of the region.

8 Likes

What is it about the early part of a century that causes fascism to come back in vogue again?

8 Likes

It would be nice if we could get past this latest patch without killing tens of millions of people again. Though even assuming we avoid an apocalyptic world war, looks like they’ll get their mass slaughter by other means by setting off a mass extinction event.

6 Likes

If you read the article, the supreme court did not disavow the thoughtcrime law, but instead said the evidence was too weak to invoke it in this particular case. Hardly a ringing victory for democracy.

4 Likes

“We don’t like you and we don’t want you here” is something a sovereign state can totally tell a foreign national at the border under most circumstances, but then maybe don’t issue that person a visa.

2 Likes

The court accepted Alqasem’s appeal, saying her desire to study in Israel undermines the premise of her alleged support for a boycott. It said that if her deportation was based on her political opinion, then the state’s order was “a radical and dangerous step” that could erode Israeli democracy.

Respectively disagree with occamscoin.

Not a lawyer, but the second line above clearly is a signal that the SC is curbing an unfounded and biased law that encroaches on the freedom of expression rights of foreigners, and Israeli citizens alike.

Edit: ‘Respectively disagree’

1 Like

That is not how I read media reports. The Supreme Court did not strike down the law (which I don’t think they could) they made it very clear that it could not be enforced without a LOT of evidence.

That is an important ruling.

P.s. and if evidence apart from political beliefs, race etc exists that someone is a threat, then they can be kept out of a country. Certainly, being a “threat” can keep you out of the US. The issue is what level of evidence/threat is needed.

1 Like

Israel’s Interior Minister Aryeh Deri likewise lamented the court’s decision, calling it a national embarrassment. “Where is our national pride? Would she also have dared in the United States to act against the state while demanding to remain and study in it?” he wrote on Twitter.

Yes.

And it is, in fact, a matter of national pride.

8 Likes

It would seem to me that if someone asks to enter a country in order to live, go to school, and travel (and pay for all this in some manner), that’s not much of a boycott of that country.
But what do I know?

3 Likes

I had exactly the same reaction to the Interior Minister’s comments.

“Act against the state”!
She was alleged to belong to a group that advocated boycotting hummus.
“Never again!” I say!

1 Like

Israel’s Interior Minister Aryeh Deri likewise lamented the court’s decision, calling it a national embarrassment. “Where is our national pride? Would she also have dared in the United States to act against the state while demanding to remain and study in it?” he wrote on Twitter.

Hey, Aryeh, we have a President of the United States who acts against our interests on a daily basis.

2 Likes

Disappointment that the new millennium didn’t bring on the Rapture, or Armageddon, or whatever fairy tale they’re pining for?

Seems to fit. Gotta find those folks something useful to do…

1 Like

Answering the question “who are the brain police?”

2 Likes

Spot on. Minister Aryeh’s ignorance about the fundamental rights enshrined in the Bill of Rights is rather alarming.

It’s good to see that her university, Hebrew University, is backing her on this.
What’s happened to Israel under the criminal Netanyahoo, is happening to us, under the criminal Trump.

1 Like

So, Israel…how about you do some humane things that make BDS a thing of the past

Boycotts exist to change things, usually for the better.

As I see it, Israel, under Likud and Netanyahu, needs some changing for the better.

Every hundred years for the past 500, there’s been a major realignment of the European-centered world order beginning more or less in the second decade of the century. The Reformation and Ottoman victories in the 1500s, Thirty Years’ War in the 1600s, Great Northern War in the 1700s, Napoleonic Wars in the 1800s, WWI in the 1900s, and now. Curious.

Israel’s Interior Minister Aryeh Deri likewise lamented the court’s decision, calling it a national embarrassment. “Where is our national pride? Would she also have dared in the United States to act against the state while demanding to remain and study in it?” he wrote on Twitter.

Is this just a complete lack of understanding of America, or a challenge to push Trump deeper into fascism?