Discussion: IRS Analyst Charged With Leaking Cohen Banking Info To Avenatti, Ronan Farrow

Does the analyst have a gofundme page yet?

17 Likes

During times of universal deceit, telling the truth becomes a revolutionary act.
– George Orwell

Still, we knew this was coming. Villains have been hiding behind unjust laws for a long time. It’s the only defense they have against the fact that just about everyone in the country disagrees with them.

ETA: I really hope a Dem president or governor pardons this guy. It seems like he acted to expose corruption at the very top of the most powerful government on Earth. If that’s not patriotism, then I guess we’re reserving that label exclusively for martyrs. In which case, I will quote Patton:

The object of war is not to die for your country but to make the other bastard die for his.

ALSO:

The GOP calls for vigilante justice, ā€œ2A remediesā€ (i.e. political assassination), openly solicits cyberattacks from hostile foreign powers. Democrats call for exposing the truth. It seems reasonable to judge the parties by their methods.

23 Likes

ā€œI will tell you this: IRS analysts, if you’re listening, I hope you’re able to find the many years of Trump’s tax returns that are missing, I think you will probably be rewarded mightily by our press.ā€

40 Likes

I always thought it was about further enriching the already wealthy.
I’ll spare you the Major General Smedley Butler quotes.

6 Likes

Not a very bright analyst if he did not know that any access to these records would be logged, and those logs reviewed once the disclosed information went public.

I am also curious if the investigators were able to bypass Whatsapp encryption i.e., is there a Facebook back door? It’s possible Fry just gave them access to his data… Again not very bright to rely on anything associated with Facebook, there are better alternatives like Signal.

I hope Farrow is paying attention.

I hope TPM is paying attention.

4 Likes

IRS Analyst John Fry looks remarkably like Avenatti. Hmm…

1 Like

HA HA, heard some similar words before.

Depends on the war, I’d say, but point taken.

our newest Reality Winner!

2 Likes

5 Likes

K, dude’s a hero (maybe), but this case is basically a data breach and it’s gonna be interesting to see what happens next.

Looking on the bright side, that inevitable ā€˜dropped shoe’ could be a masterpiece (maybe?).

3 Likes

But certainly a brave one.

Why the ad hominem attack? I’m sure he was well aware of the consequences of his act.

12 Likes

Just to be a total contrarian, when laws are made to protect people’s privacy, or, for that matter, national security, the government can’t, and can’t be expected to, make ā€œunless it was for a good causeā€ exceptions that aren’t in the law. Because it’s just a short hop and a skip from there to incessant strategic leaking by political appointees to embarrass or harm political enemies, which is not a hypothetical concern under present circumstances.

Revealing government fraud, abuse or illegality is one thing, and has some legal protection. Something like this? No. In cases like this, people act at their own risk and shouldn’t do it if they’re not prepared to do the time if they get caught.

That said, it’s the ethical responsibility of recipients, whether lawyers or journalists, to do everything possible to protect sources for information like this, precisely because they have no legal liability on them for receiving them. And that’s what made the Intercept’s ineptitude (and that’s giving them the benefit of a doubt I don’t actually give them) that led to Reality Winner’s imprisonment a disgrace.

18 Likes

Great Orwell quote. Amazing times we live in. Civil servant exposes corruption and IRS is turned upside down to find him. Security services say Russians meddled in election, crickets. In fact Trump believes Putin.

12 Likes

But there are SARs reports on these suspicious men.

2 Likes

If there’s any law prohibiting republication of such confidential material, illegally provided, then Avenatti’s also in a world of hurt. And he’s got enough self-inflicted problems already.

He must have also known at the outset how the inevitable trumpptweets would read when caught, basically off with his head but with a lot of !!! and misspellings.

1 Like

I’m inclined to doubt there is a software backdoor to Whatsapp although it wouldn’t surprise me if Facebook was weakening some of its armor to mine metadata. I’m also fairly sure FB wouldn’t divulge how to the government or any one else regardless. There are better alternatives to Whatsapp in any case.

But the spymasters wouldn’t be running after the software I think – too many changes coming too fast, too much variability – or even the OS when it would be far easier to insist a backdoor exist in the essential communication chips common to all hardware. Secure encryption certainly exists as an idea but I don’t believe it exists as a practical matter; it depends on who wants the information and how much they want it. JMO

3 Likes

I am guessing Robert Mueller did not need Avenatti’s help on this.

1 Like