Discussion: Iraq War Vet Tammy Duckworth Says Shinseki 'Has To Go'

Especially the kind of politics we re seeing now

2 Likes

This is what they mean when the say its a contact sport. Morally and/or logically, he may have been the right guy for the job. But that is only a maybe. Politically, this wasn’t a fight worth having for the WH. It would cost a great deal of political capital, tank Obama’s ratings for a few months, and give republicans a battleground where we are defending…letting veterans die.

People can parse it however they like, but at the end of the day, the American people will lock into ā€œletting veterans dieā€ā€¦and that is NOT a news story you want running over the summer (4th of July, anyone? want to guess how that story gets played then?)

Shinseki really didn’t do himself any favors during the hearings either. He didn’t come across as a man with a plan…he came across as a guy saying, ā€œwhat problem? I was told everything is great!ā€ Rightly or wrongly, it all just adds up to his resignation.

3 Likes

Hope they will look at the funding that the repubs have been cutting from the agency.What did they expect ?

1 Like

What would be real interesting is if he nominated a former Command Sergeant Major instead of yet another General.

Yes, anybody with common sense knows there is an egregious political double standard. But a whole lot of people have no sense and the rest don’t know what a double standard is.
I don’t know if the electorate’s partisan bias and ignorance would be lessened if Dems stood their ground against it. I suspect recent history shows otherwise.
That seems to force Dems to react to public perception rather than presenting alternative responses…and Gd forbid, solutions.

Fair points.

Personally, I think it has to be a relief. The place is so screwed up by decades of underfunding and having a patchwork IT system that I think I’d rather be HHS than VA sec at this point.

I’m a VA consumer, and I would have backed Shinseki to the end, but I’m happy for the guy.