Discussion: How Kim Davis Became An Unlikely Martyr

Discussion for article #240249

So, when (not if) she again violates the judge’s ruling that she allow her subordinates to issue the licenses, what’s next? I’m assuming jail and fines. Are we then stuck in an infinite loop? Davis goes to jail -> minions issue licenses -> Davis gets out of jail -> Davis orders minions to not issue licenses -> Davis goes to jail …

If she is determined not to ever issue licenses, is there any remedy short of changing the law that will break the cycle?

2 Likes

The Nazis, too, believed they were doing God’s will when they used the power of the government to persecute the Jews (and, ironically enough, persecute homosexuals as well). Our Founding Fathers were smart and prescient enough to keep God out of the equation when creating our system of government. If you don’t like that system of government, there are lots of intolerant theocracies around the world to choose from.

LOL!

 Survivor Furious That “Eye Of The Tiger” Was Used In Kim Davis Video, Considers Suing To Protect Integrity
2 Likes

We need to keep some things straight here.

Davis is NOT a martyr to an oppressive government forcing her to comprise her “religious freedom.”

David IS the oppressive government. She is an elected County Clerk in Kentucky who is using the power of the state to deny the constitutional right to marry to certain individuals who don’t meet her personal religious test.

Davis is NOT Martin Luther King. Davis is Orvial Faubus standing in the school house door. David is George Wallace standing in the university door.

President Eisenhower federalized the Arkansas National Guard and sent the 101st Airborne Division of the US Army to assure black children could go to school in Little Rock in 1957.

President Kennedy federalized the Alabama National Guard and ordered it to see that black students could attend the University of Alabama in 1963.

If Davis again interferes with the issuing of marriage licenses in Rowan County, Kentucky she will find herself in the custody of the US Marshall’s and back in jail. In this country, governments do not deny lawfully issued court orders citing “God’s Will” or the government’s “religious freedom.”

That is an unconstitutional establishment of religion. We don’t expect “Liberty Counsel” to see it that way. We do expect the US Supreme Court to see it that way.

If Davis were just an employee of the County Clerk and other clerks would issue marriage licenses, we could talk about making at “religious accommodation” under the circumstances. But Davis is not a mere employee. She is the ELECTED County Clerk. Davis IS the GOVERNMENT, There is NO accommodation available for “the Government” here – on;y obedience to the courts or the consequences of disobedience.

9 Likes

Too bad the media gives these Christianist/Dominionists outsized importance and a sympathetic tone in their coverage. Would like to see the author address why the media in general seems to prop up these boneheads when the law is clear, and the separation of Church and State is the law of the land to all but the most dogmatic purveyors of these ongoing spectacles.

And btw, new word of the day for me…“hoosegow”. Thanks for that one.

1 Like

What’s the ol’ Joan Baez line: “Martyrs are best when they’re made of stone / A savior’s a nuisance to live with at home…”

Kim Davis is just the hypocritical attention whore who was the useful tool, or fool, looked for and found by the shyster lawyers from the Falwell arm of the American TEAliban and nothing more.

THIS is their ‘martyr’ for “Traditional Christian Marriage”? rotflmao

Favorite picture of this entire travesty.
Let’s play: "Where in the World is Cubanadian Cruz?"

^^^^ lmao

2 Likes

Rethugs just cannot stop stealing songs, and they keep embarrassing themselves when the songwriters/singers slap them down.

1 Like

Keep in mind that Thomas More was a committed inquisitor and happily sent Lutheran heretics to the stake. Had it not been for Henry VIII, he could well have eventually become a kind of English “Torquemada”

Thomas More died in defense of an authoritarian intolerance much more powerful than a mere king’s, however, for he died believing in God and in the authority of the pope and the Catholic Church. As Lord Chancellor, he had imprisoned and interrogated Lutherans, sometimes in his own house, and sent six reformers to be burned at the stake, and he had not done this just so that he might die for slender modern scruple, for anything as naked as the naked self. This drained, contemporary view of More, which admires not what he believed but how he believed-his “certainty,” only-is thinly secular, and represents nothing more than the retired religious yearning of a nonreligious age. - James Wood, “Essays on Literature and Belief”

http://www.luminarium.org/renlit/wood.htm

2 Likes

Actually she is not a martyr for “most” christians…My Mother is hardcore babtist and she has said the over riding comments she hears at church is this woman is making a mockery of religion and that NO ONE can break the laws of this country and use religion as a reason. TPM needs to get off the “everyone” bandwagon and look around…there are no mass rallys anywhere but her lil burg in Kentucky…you know the place where your sister could be your cousin or wife.

1 Like

She was able to throw a lot of weight into her martyrdom

Simple. FOLLOW THE MONEY.
The MSM LOVES Bible-Thumpers because they draw more eyeballs to their toilet paper commercials (i.e. “If it bleeds it leads.” Face it, there is no more Journalism on TV. Only “Infotainment”.
“Jerry Springer” has replaced “Walter Cronkite” and the only thing that matters is RATINGS.
Thank Saint Ronnie the Raygun for disposing of the “Fairness” doctrine that required the networks to have impartial, fact-based news broadcasts run by REAL JOURNALISTS, not “talking heads” paid to look good.
Why in 1998 FOX News successfully defended itself from a Libel lawsuit by getting the courts to agree that it was NOT a “News Program” but an “Entertainment” program, therefor it could manufacture any “news” it wanted and did not have to be “factual”. It’s been all downhill from there.

1 Like

Unlikely? more like that was her goal

It’s the INTERNET’S SOCIAL HULLABALOO

The thing is, though, that Davis’ um, complex history of marriage and relationships works to her benefit among her fundie friends – in their eyes, her story is not one of hypocrisy and double standards, but one of redemption and salvation, similar to the parable of the Prodigal Son in the Bible. To her supporters it proves that she’s the real deal.

1 Like

The only - and absolutely the only element that could make for a slightly legitimate philosophical discussion is the fact that when a marriage certificate/ license is issued by her office, it is not just- fill out a form, pay some money - and then get a plain generic state of Kentucky document. Supposedly the document has printed on it something like “Issued by Kim Davis” and has a facsimile of her signature. Kind of like the North Carolina “Elevator Lady” Labor Commissioner Cherie Berry - whose name & signature is on a certificate in every single elevator in North Carolina

But … ultimately …Kim Davis’s argument is specious - Kim Davis has to get it through her thick skull that she is only issuing a certificate / license for what is permitted by law - her signature only signifies that the marriage complies with the law - her action is neither an approval or disapproval of the content of the marriage - regardless of how big of a judgmental bitch that she may be! She has to separate her religious beliefs from her professional state job responsibilities.

1 Like

Actually no. The Nazi’s mostly hated the Jew Jesus and SS members were quietly encouraged to leave organized religion. Himmler even dabbled with some revitalization of Nordic Wotan worship. Hitler and his chief idealogue Rosenberg perceived organized religion, esp. catholicism, as one of their main enemies.

1 Like

I hope it is not nitpicking, but

Kentucky GOP Senate nominee Matt Bevan

is actually the GOP nominee for governor this year, after he unsuccessfully challenged Sen. McConnell for the Senate nomination last year. And his name is “Bevin”, not Bevan.

“We tolerate no one in our ranks who attacks the ideas of Christianity, in fact our movement is Christian.” — Adolf Hitler, October 27, 1928

“My feelings as a Christian points me to my Lord and Savior as a fighter. It points me to the man who once in loneliness, surrounded only by a few followers, recognized these Jews for what they were and summoned men to fight against them and who, God’s truth! was greatest not as a sufferer but as a fighter. In boundless love as a Christian and as a man I read through the passage which tells us how the Lord at last rose in His might and seized the scourge to drive out of the Temple the brood of vipers and adders. How terrific was His fight for the world against the Jewish poison. To-day, after two thousand years, with deepest emotion I recognize more profoundly than ever before in the fact that it was for this that He had to shed His blood upon the Cross. As a Christian I have no duty to allow myself to be cheated, but I have the duty to be a fighter for truth and justice… And if there is anything which could demonstrate that we are acting rightly it is the distress that daily grows. For as a Christian I have also a duty to my own people… When I go out in the morning and see these men standing in their queues and look into their pinched faces, then I believe I would be no Christian, but a very devil if I felt no pity for them, if I did not, as did our Lord two thousand years ago, turn against those by whom to-day this poor people is plundered and exploited.” – Adolf Hitler, April 12, 1922

Hitler remained a Catholic all his life, and the Catholic Church never excommunicated him.

“Gott Mit Uns” (translation “God is with us”) emblazoned on common Nazi soldier belt-buckles during World War II.

1 Like