Discussion: Family: Otto Warmbier, US Student Freed From North Korea, Has Died

This news is so very, very sad and, with complicated political implications. One can only have sincere sympathy for his family.

8 Likes

He made a juvenile mistake that in most communities/countries would have resulted in a scary interaction with authorities, then a fine and then a story he could tell later about what a dumb ass he was. Most of us have a few of those stories to tell.

I am a proud progressive on most issues but there is no place for repressive regimes like North Korea. Unless the NK military joins with the oppressed people to overthrow this medieval regime I am afraid that Kim and his cohorts are sowing the seeds that will lead to their own destruction. I hope there can be some kind of peace for Otto Warmbier and his family.

4 Likes

Iā€™m a loving progressive, but the only way to travel to North Korea is one-way on the back of a nuke, a la Dr. Strangelove.

Itā€™s truly a pity that our friends in Seoul are so near that we canā€™t risk their lives to just wipe out that scum.

If he even did. The ā€˜beautyā€™ of dictatorships is that you canā€™t believe anything, most especially a ā€˜confessionā€™. Yes, he may have done something, but itā€™s also as likely that he didnā€™t do anything, and merely happened to be at the wrong place and American.

2 Likes

This outcome is, of course, tragic and only confirms what we already knew, which is that North Korea is run by a brutal totalitarian dictator - who had his own uncle and half-brother horrifically murderd. I just canā€™t understand how the parents could have shown such irresponsibility as to give their son approval (which I heard the father state that they had) to make such a deathly risky trip. After all, the U.S. is still at a technical state of war with N.K., and has been since the early 1950ā€™s. Plus, the batshit crazy has long run deep in the Kim Jong lineage.

3 Likes

This kid was probably stronger than anyone he dealt with in NKā€¦certainly the childish Kim. Thereā€™s a ton of good stuff on NKā€¦it should be read. The previous NK doctors had the persona to fool their people and intimidate the rest of NK leadership. Including military leaders. Kim the Kid does not. many folks that have spent a life studying NK and itā€™s politics are convinced the Boy King Kim is that last of his line. NK could be a much better place but to stay as it is it must keep itā€™s people ignorant and afraid. They have perfected isolation techniques but theyā€™re up against new forms of information flow they canā€™t hope to keep up with. Kimā€™s groomers know this. Itā€™s over in our lifetime.

1 Like

I am dumbfounded that anyone would wish to travel to NK. Or go hiking on the border for Iran. People do it though.

4 Likes

Well, the people weā€™d be nuking are just as much a victim of the NK regime as Otto Warmbier was, so I donā€™t know if that would accomplish much. And are we all that much better in certain ways? Screenshot from the current TPM frontage:

i heard that he and his group were warned not to go. Would this be by the state department?

North Korea killed Otto Warmbier with probable 17 months of continuous sleep deprivation torture.

And yet we (the US) honor President Duterte of the the Philippines, who is responsible for the extrajudicial killing of thousands of ā€œsuspectedā€ drug dealers and street children. One evil does not excuse another. A little moral consistency would be good here.