Discussion: Court Rules Florida Can Stop Doctors From Asking Patients About Guns

Florida. Leading the Nation in protecting the profit margins of Death Merchants.

Makes sense to me. My doctor is welcome to stick her finger in my anus, but I draw the line at questions about my wellbeing.

1 Like

A number of Republican-controlled states have passed laws requiring that women desiring to terminate a pregnancy have to listen to anti-abortion propaganda from medical personnel, yet in another Republican-controlled state it’s against the law for a doctor to inquire about weapons at home.

In other words: Republicans have a tremendous interest in sticking their hands up your uterus, but when it comes to guns, it’s strictly hands-off.

2 Likes

Don’t ask, just start telling “If you have a gun, here is what you should do” in cases where the patient is a parent.

Because doctors and patients both have infinite time.

Which one is the party of “small government” again?

1 Like

Doctors who work for corporations must be so confused!

2 Likes

Wasn’t this on a, um, recent episode of Drunk History? [incoherent].
Face plant.

1 Like

All right Freedin of Speech people! Where y’all at?

So the Second Amendment trumps the First Amendment. Constitutional math like that eventually equals zero for non-Goopers.

No, a doctor would never say anything about this. Never ask a new family if they have a car, and suggest they get a child seat. Never discuss hazards in the home and how to avoid them. No, never would come to mind to discuss with a patient under any circumstance. And, of course, there’s a requirement that the patient answer, or what? Doctor/patient privilege and other laws keeps these conversations confidential, so what’s the issue?

But that’s not the point of your stupid argument. The doctor is not infringing on ownership by asking the question, but is asking about the existence of something known to cause harm. But second amendment trumps everything, right? How is a doctor discussing guns in the home infringing on the right to bear arms? Slippery slope? Ridiculous.

2 Likes

The equal rights amendment never passed, so women aren’t guaranteed rights, just what the legislatures and courts allow. It’s all so simple for those screaming about the libtards taking away their freedumbs, and also deny there’s anything in the freedom loving GOP agenda against women.

It"s like a card game, 2 beats 1, and, according to state’s righters, 10 beats them all. The constitution itself? It’s just made up of articles, they’re just part of the original so less than 1; and the amendments after 10, not by the founders so not original intent.

That’s just a ridiculous comment. Pediatricians ask parents about all kinds of things which they think might be safety issues in their homes and travel - Where are the cleaning products kept? Do you always wear seat belts? Are there safety gates to keep toddlers from falling down stairs? etc. They do this as part of routine physical exams. If a patient comes with a specific medical pain or problem, the doctor treats that - there’s no conflict here except in your imagination.

2 Likes

I am going to add something else here which is absolutely mind-boggling about those who resent questions by a doctor whose primary goal is to keep kids healthy and safe. One’s responsibilities as a parent are more important than anything else one does or wants or prefers - yet you keep articulating that your preferences and rights to own a weapon, keep it anywhere you want, refuse to answer questions about it, etc. are your first concern. If you are a parent (or claim to care about kids), I have to seriously question your maturity and priorities.

Man changing tire unintentionally shoots self in stomach

A 32-year-old Corsicana, Texas man was returning to his truck after a
day of rafting on the river in New Braunfels when he noticed a bulge in
one of the truck tires. He decided to change the tire before driving
home. When he went to retrieve a jack from underneath the back seat he
instead grabbed a loaded, unlocked 30-30 rifle that he had stored under
the seat. He unintentionally discharged the gun, shooting himself in the abdomen.

MTA officer shot when colleague’s gun unintentionally goes off

A New York City MTA officer was shot in the stomach when a colleague’s
gun unintentionally discharged inside an administrative building. A Tunnel Authority officer was placing her service weapon in a gun locker when she hit the trigger. The bullet ricocheted inside the locker before traveling across the room and striking the other officer in the stomach.

In-laws unintentionally shoot each other in two separate incidents

One family in Chaska, Minnesota is having a rough week. First, a man who was negligently handling a handgun unintentionally shot his father-in-law in the foot.

A few days later, the man who was shot in the foot was also mishandling a
handgun when he unintentionally shot himself in the hand. The bullet
passed through his hand and struck his wife in the stomach.

This week, Florida Marlins pitcher Jose Ceda revealed his secret to his team - two years ago he shot his best friend. While the details remain unclear, Ceda unintentionally shot his friend in the stomach. The bullet penetrated the spine.

Wife thought husband was intruder, shot him six times

Angelicque T. was awakened by a noise so she sent her husband, Stephen, to investigate. According to police, “At some point, Stephen was shot by Angelicque, who said she thought her husband was an intruder.”

The couple’s business website states, “Stephen and his wife of 16 years,
Angelicque, are the proud parents of five children. They reside in
Bend, Oregon and serve their community by helping multiple charities and
churches in Bend and across the Pacific to the Philippines.”

Stephen was shot with a handgun five times in the stomach and once in the wrist.

Man unintentionally shoots girlfriend while putting handgun away

An unidentified San Antonio, Texas man in his 20s was concerned when he
heard someone knocking on the door of his apartment Friday night. He
responded by getting out his 9mm handgun and “racked it so it would fire
if he pulled the trigger.” He went to bed that night, leaving the
loaded gun, with the bullet in the chamber, on the coffee table next to
the living room futon. The next afternoon he was watching television
and decided to put the gun away. According to police, he grabbed the gun and “didn’t realize it was loaded and accidentally pulled the trigger.”

The bullet hit his girlfriend, also in her 20s, as she came walking
around the corner in the apartment. She was struck in the stomach.

Plenty more where that came from.

1 Like

Actually yes they do. Not necessarily knives or cars, but depending on your condition or the condition of the loved one you’re taking care of, doctors and nurses can and do ask their patients about their living spaces, accessibility, objects in the home that could possibly cause harm.

I know you’re just trolling, but I wanted to take a moment to point out that you’re wrong, though I doubt you care.

“unless information is relevant to patient’s medical care or safety or safety of others, inquiries regarding firearm ownership or possession should not be made.”

Oh, never mind all the hubbub. According to the language in the law itself, it’s perfectly reasonable and legal to ask any and all patients about firearms.

RickScott aiding and abetting deaths of kids in homes with adults

afflicted with *MGTB Syndrome.

*MoreGunsThanBrains