Conservative Justices Express Hostility To Biden Administration’s Power

The conservative contingent of the Supreme Court questioned agencies’ ability to mandate the COVID-19 vaccine Friday, often asking why that power shouldn’t be left to Congress instead. 


This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://talkingpointsmemo.com/?p=1400447

You don’t understand, Mister President, Sam Alito makes the decisions around here.

27 Likes

Decisions handed down by the Reactionary Five (and often Six) are piling up a powerful case for expanding the Supreme Court–if, that is, the nation survives the depredations of “conservative” judges, legislators, and presidents long enough to have a viable future.

If the Democrats can hang onto the House and Senate in '22, a thorough overhaul of the Court must be on the agenda.

67 Likes

“You’re incorrigible, you little zipper neck! Oh, all right. Thirteen has always been my lucky number.”

#ExpandAndUnpack

31 Likes

Time to shut down the Supreme Court.

5 Likes

Many will suffer needlessly with this version of “justice”.

44 Likes

I am not amused. “Existing policies and procedures based on historical precedent? What are they even? The National Committee for Emergency Response will almost certainly take up the matter of your currently burning house at its next quarterly board meeting three months from this date.”. ffs.

23 Likes

Here it comes. I was wondering when these clown would go full on wingnut…my wait is over. Forget anything good for USA coming out of that foul SCOTUS…it’s all about GOP there. It will be fun to watch these horrible people walk all this feigned “anti executive” crap back when a GOP’er is in office.

44 Likes

How much longer are we gonna keep pretending that our 1787 constitution is still adequate? Are progressives ready for what comes next? I guarantee you that the GQP and its enablers are, and their vision is A LOT closer to the Handmaid’s Tale than it is, say, the Basic Law of Germany

22 Likes

So what would be the purpose of an executive branch of government then? No need for political appointees, and then no jobs to handout to big backers either.

So if Hobby Lobby does one thing and Michael’s another and it becomes a lawsuit the Supreme Court has to decide, after months going thru the lower courts. Sounds like we’ll need more Justices to actively legislate from the benches.

I’d pick Hillary and Obama first for expansion, then people like Katie Porter or Michael Brune or some smart liberal actor or someone like E.O.Wilson.

13 Likes

“1787 constitution”
The dead rule the living. The zombies won.

20 Likes

Apathy about voting got us here, when it was plain that elections for POTUS and Congress weigh on who (and what) is selected for the Supreme Court.

People are less apathetic now.

It had better be enough.

29 Likes

Exactly what we should have expected from this bunch of GOP Political hacks.

16 Likes

Yeah this sucks. But her emails…

18 Likes

Anyone else notice that Josh made Kate and Other-Josh do dueling articles?

Is this like “whomever gets more comments wins” in a celebrity-deathmatch sort of way?

6 Likes

I work in a business where you learn to size up someone’s character pretty quickly.

Amy Coney Barrett looks evil.

18 Likes

"Why doesn’t Congress have a say in this, why isn’t it the primary responsibility of the states?” Chief Justice John Roberts asked, accusing the administration of using disparate agency mandates as a “workaround” to replace congressional action.

Ok, then, when Russia or China invades the US, the POTUS will order the military to defend all States, except whatever State you’re in. You’re on your own because States’ Responsibility. Good luck!

7 Likes

He’s actually making the right argument here. Congress could make this whole thing moot by passing one single goddamned law explicitly authorizing DOL and HHS to mandate vaccines.

11 Likes

Hmm…I saw a picture of her standing next to Roberts earlier this morning, and she looked an awful lot like Melania T rumpp.

4 Likes

So why didn’t T rumpp and McTurtle do that when this all got started?

2 Likes