Birx Likens Coronavirus Outbreaks In Hot-Spot States To ‘Three New Yorks’ | Talking Points Memo

White House coronavirus task force expert Dr. Deborah Birx warned Friday that the coronavirus surge is “very serious,” likening its spread in surging states like Florida, Texas and California to the outbreak this past spring in New York — which still ranks highest in the country in its staggering death toll for the virus.


This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://talkingpointsmemo.com/?p=1322185

Too little, too late, Debbi.

6 Likes

America is breathlessly waiting to scarf up your mis-timed, dumbed down info, Doc.

9 Likes

Dr. Birx…

  1. Why did CDC issue updated guidelines to reopen schools that passed the responsibility to parents in stopping Covid spread?

  2. If Trump’s rally in Jacksonville was cancelled for health reasons, then why is CDC still recommending to reopen schools in person?

  3. What say you about Trump acing his cognitive test?

564D86B8-DFE6-468C-83D1-4EDAB52CB6AF

13 Likes

This is what Drs Birx and Fauci are up against: the newest Lincoln Project ad, titled “Failure”. Brutal.

16 Likes

These people are telling us what we’ve known for weeks and months. How is this remotely helpful?
@george_c Do you know where these videos show up other than sites like this? Does the general public see them? Preaching to the converted is not what we need.

3 Likes

Birx has been playing it both ways—Feeding egos instead of dispassionately being the scientist in the room, assisting in wresting control of the Covid data from the CDC in order to control the narrative to feed those same egos—-she can’t reclaim her credibility now. She told these suckers the outlook was rosy. When you do a 180 you need to first acknowledge you were wrong. Fauci can’t pitch but he is a straight shooter—and they(she included) froze him out for politics.
To me she’s just part of the campaign.

8 Likes

New York, New York, New York?!?

They go too far. Frank will rise from the grave and smite them.

2 Likes

Zilla – Lincoln Project advertises heavily in Red and Toss-up states.

4 Likes

They send out such great messages. Don’t do TV so I just wondered where they were hitting.

4 Likes

Slowly, so his base doesn’t catch on, Trump is beginning to set himself up as the savior from COVID19 because he got fake info from top experts.
This is not his fault.

4 Likes

Also in DC, for the yooge audience of one.

4 Likes

So if it’s like new york, the shelter in place orders will be issued in . . .

Oh, never. Gotcha.

6 Likes

Has she decried the attacks on Fauci yet?

He and his family now have their own security detail, necessary only thanks to Trump.

2 Likes

So from that article:

While a single case of COVID-19 in a school would likely not warrant closing the entire school, the CDC said if the transmission of the virus within a school is higher than that of the community, or if the school is the source of an outbreak, administrators should work with health officials to determine if temporary school closure is necessary.

If.

This is basically a slightly modified “let it wash through”.

9 Likes

Here’s a glimmer of hope - I haven’t seen anyone in a public place without a mask for about 2 weeks now in Mesa, AZ.

Like I said, a glimmer.

12 Likes

Florida & Texas - mimicking New York in term of scary escalation of number of cases… Perilously close to health care system colapse… but not emulating the strict controls that were put in place to wrestle the incidents rate downward.
Handicapped by a dogmatic compulsion to make every healthcare decision conform to Trump’s Political agenda. Effectively decisions are being made to let / cause people to die in order to remain aligned with Trump.

California - huge population with erratic compliance with / enforcement of - guidelines… unclear as to whether we are seeing a resurgence of initial phase/wave … or … a sort of wave one - part b … or … a second wave?

5 Likes

Sorry, AoC, but she is a fucking bitch. There’s no reason to use that phrasing except to please Trump, and to incite political blame gaming. Birx is the WORST national public health figure I’ve seen in my life. She’s a disgrace to every profession she has worked in.

5 Likes

One thing that Trump is great at is at inducing corruption, he may be an idiot for everything else, but he is good at guessing what a person covets, sometimes he uses it to expose and humiliate them like in the case of Mitt Romney, but many others have he has used to to do his corrupt biding and then discarded with their reputation shattered like Gordon Sondland and Jeff Sessions.

I don’t know what Dr. Deborah Birx wanted, but like many others she is getting shit and her reputation damaged beyond repair. And it is a shame because, I am told by a person that works in her previous outfit " President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief" that she had a legendary status there.

7 Likes

Hey, it was a very hard test. Very difficult. Is it a lion? Is it a giraffe? There are good answers on both sides.

4 Likes