A Court Fight Is Brewing Over A Ballot Slip-Up Affecting 29K Pittsburgh-Area Voters | Talking Points Memo

Republicans have gone to federal court to make it easier for them to challenge the ballots of nearly 29,000 Pittsburgh-area voters who were caught up in ballot-sending flub in recent weeks.


This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://talkingpointsmemo.com/?p=1340323
1 Like

"I don’t think its in everyone’s interest to have a bunch of election day lawsuits "
True but it is definitely in Donald Trump’s interest.

38 Likes

I don’t know the make-up of the Allegheny County voters, but won’t it be so delish if these two candidates challenge their Republican voter’s ballots over Democratic voter’s ballots?

8 Likes

Bush v. Gore had a clause in the holding that said this:

[> “Our consideration is limited to the present circumstances, for the problem of equal protection in election processes generally presents many complexities.”[60]

Legal TPMers, was this suggesting that the decision not be used to determine precedent?

15 Likes

Should the Pittsburgh Pirates sue the GOP for theft of their trademarked name?

34 Likes

They’ve got lists by party registration. I’m sure they’ll kindly waive challenges for some voters to speed the process.

21 Likes

Republicans have gone to federal court to make it easier for them to challenge the ballots

Well, of course they did. I mean, when you know you’re winning ….

19 Likes

Wasn’t the vendor who screwed up, the person who flew a Trump flag over his factory?

Hmm …

7 Likes

If the Republicans get their way, it could create a messy and confusing situation

Well, that’s how they govern, so it makes sense.

10 Likes

Last gasps of a dying party.

26 Likes

“I don’t think it’s in everyone’s best interest to have a bunch of Election Day lawsuits over these ballots when there hopefully could be some agreement on the procedures that will be implemented,” he (judge ranjan) said.

Um, judge, I hope you said that because you had to, otherwise I’m going to have to “oh my sweet country mouse” your ass.

One note: this judge was appointed by morBotus, but he did a few weeks ago effectively toss the GOP’s PA election fraud suit by ordering them to produce evidence of such fraud or aver that they had none.

21 Likes

Fucking traitor. Like he thinks he doesn’t owe them for his appointment.

7 Likes

I’m pretty confident the gop checked the demographics of those 29k voters quite carefully before launching this hogwash.

16 Likes

I’m not sure it’s the same vendor, but that was an ohio company that was printing ballots for several states.

6 Likes

Knowing who appointed the judge is the way to bet on how they will rule, but it doesn’t always go that way.

6 Likes

I just wish it wasn’t a shock when they actually make the proper decision.

16 Likes

Yep. They knew it was bogus legal thinking so they made it a one-time only

22 Likes

But they will be disenfranchising GOP voters, too. Maybe they know that the overwhelming number of disputed ballots will be for Biden?

4 Likes

That line has spawned a great deal of commentary, to say the least.

The most charitable interpretation is indeed what you suggest - that the decision cannot be cited as binding precedent in future disputes. A quick search on Lexis Nexus shows about 500 citations to Bush v. Gore, so… you can decide for yourself how well that worked for them.

More cynically, that line was viewed by many commentators as an admission by the Republican appointed majority that the decision was poorly considered and politically motivated, and they wanted an out in case it came back to bite them.

I’ll let you pick the interpretation which you prefer.

28 Likes

Don’t worry. If it comes to that, the Democrats have their own lists… and they can make challenges too.

3 Likes