5th Circuit Panel Temporarily Pauses Order Blocking Government From Flagging Social Media Misinformation

A panel of 5th Circuit judges granted the Biden administration’s request for an administrative stay of a widely panned lower court decision that blocked wide swaths of the government from flagging misinformation to the companies that operate social media sites. 


This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://talkingpointsmemo.com/?p=1463320
1 Like

Using unusually harsh language, the DOJ wrote that Doughty’s ruling “reflects numerous legal errors” and that its scope is an “abuse of discretion.” It also asked that, at the very least, the relief be constrained to the named parties in the suit so as to not affect the “vast universe of government actions lacking any connection to plaintiffs.”

Typical right wing nonsense, of course, but at some point, SCOTUS will get this case. I don’t think we can have any confidence that the Supremes will find for Biden.

Now, if GQP takes the government again, all bets are off.

12 Likes

A ruling too crazy for the 5th Circuit.

THAT’S a crazy ass ruling.

24 Likes

So no freedom of speech for government officials?

9 Likes

I will take a wait and see attitude before I applaud the 5th Circuit for this temporary pause.

18 Likes

I will take this as a good sign for now. You just know this will end up before the Purchased Court, so I’ll wait.

16 Likes

I heard that Judge Terry Doughty is paid $300 a day by Russia, is a member of the Ku Klux Klan, and spends his weekends sexually abusing puppies.

The government says I am promoting misinformation. Hah! Judge Terry Doughty says my rights are more important.

/Sarcasm

27 Likes

Since the “facts alleged” in the actual suit are complete and utter bullshit, the TRO was the only thing that really matters. The plaintiffs filed in this district because they knew they’d get the nutter judge that they got, (he’s the only rat in this particular shit-house).

15 Likes

It was the plan all along to get orange man into the WH so he could appoint judges who didn’t care about democracy and Doughty’s (“a consistently anti-Biden administration judge”) doing just what was expected of him

23 Likes

I think the plan was to get a (any) warm republican body with a pen in his hand in order to nominate whichever judges the Federalist Society fed to him.

12 Likes

I have the feeling the whole right wing judiciary is lousy with billionaire flatterers and all manner of side deals and hustles, with maybe Texas, and the 5th Circuit, the deepest in the mud.

The trouble with rewarding or relying on bombthrowers is that they have as little care for their supporters as they do their enemies. The far right is shitting the bed of all manner of good old Republican scams.

If you take HRC’s vast right wing conspiracy, and turbocharge it with evangelical money, well, the doughty peers of the grand fortunes of America might be dragged into the light, if even to cut the throat of the interloper.

My bet is homeboy went too far and there has been a quiet conversation. We should see no more grandstanding with this fruitcake.

3 Likes

Doughty, a consistently anti-Biden administration judge, had referred to the administration’s attempt to restrict COVID-19 misinformation as “Orwellian” and “dystopian” in his original ruling. He rehashed some of those examples of government “censorship” in his denial of the stay request.

Doughty’s ruling was doubleplusbad.

9 Likes

I’ve forgotten who the other repubs were who were competing with orange man but I do recall Jeb! A wuss in many ways but maybe not so wussy as to roll over and play dead for the Federalist Society. His brother was the stupidest prez we’ve ever had (until orange man) but he might have had some influence on him and told him ixnay on extreme right wingers.

10 Likes

Doughty will, doubtless, reverse his ruling if His Favorite President ™ is reelected and has his DoJ start sending warnings to the SPLC.
Of course, then it’ll be, “Sometimes you have to burn the village to save it.”

7 Likes

If fundraising means anything orange boy will not be reelected. He has raised $35M and DeSatan $20M. It’s disgusting that money in these amounts is measured as the road to victory.

19 Likes

Far right figures shitting beds, a terrible image to ponder for too long.

2 Likes

You got it. The rightwing gets the “freedom” to lie. The government does not have the right to correct or speak. Up is down. White is black. We are in a hell created by the rightwing.

7 Likes

Because you’re all wondering who appointed them: Clinton, Obama, and Trump, respectively.

8 Likes

I’ll grant you Jeb but if it had been Cruz then we’d have the same lot as we got with President Poopy Diapers

2 Likes

Cruz hasn’t got a prayer to win any seat other than in Texas and even that’s beginning to look dicey.

8 Likes