Why a Disputed Election in the Senate Leaves Many Open Questions

Originally published at: Why a Disputed Election in the Senate Leaves Many Open Questions - TPM – Talking Points Memo

Now that some Senate Republicans say they’ll stage a floor fight to block Mary Peltola from being seated should she win on Tuesday, we are compelled to try to figure out: how would that work? Few can predict, largely because the Senate is an institution governed more by norms than by law. What is clear…

The current class of senators up for election includes 22 Republicans and 11 Democrats. On January 3rd their terms expire and they are no longer eligible to vote until the incoming class is sworn in. That leaves the voting composition of the Senate at 34 Democrats (+2 Independents) and 31 Republicans. Doesn’t that mean Democrats will have control of the chamber for the credentialing process? As long as Peltola’s election is certified, it seems like that should be the end of the issue. I’d be very interested to hear other perspectives on this.

2 Likes

It’s not clear what effect the two Dans will have on the outcome (Alaska has ranked choice voting), nor is it clear whether there’s a crime.

According to the Alaska Supreme Court, there was no crime. That seems pretty damn clear.

1 Like

Unfortunately the Franken case shows Republicans can keep the seat open a long time. The Minnesota recount didn’t take long, but then Coleman made enormous numbers of frivolous challenges which each had to be adjudicated. Even that took just minutes per ballot, but then the Coleman campaign made hopeless appeals to the courts. Hopeless as they were, each took a long time to hold a hearing and the courts to release their rulings and opinions. Trump is a master of court delays, so I bet Peltola’s seating could be held up most of a year.

IANAL, and certainly not an election law lawyer, but the outcome on Nov 3 makes it pretty certain that Peltola will be seated if certified by the state. My election law question is whether the fundamental constitutional rule (“Each House shall be the Judge of the Elections, Returns and Qualifications of its own Members”) establishes a process entirely separate from any judicial process. Court cases could have two statuses when the Senate convenes: a suit might lead a judge to order the state to delay certification; or a suit might be filed after certification, or the judge of a suit filed before might not enjoin certification. In either case, though, the Senate is still the “Judge” of the “Election”. In the Minnesota case, the Senate waited for the state’s certification during the legal process, which delayed certification action according to Minnesota law – which was probably the right course of action. But it’s not clear, given the Article I language, that the Senate had to wait for such certification, even though it would be prudent to do so in most cases. In the Alaska case, it seems likely that the Senate would also wait if the certification was delayed because of state litigation. But if there were Federal investigation ongoing from the corrupt DOJ and corrupt FBI, or if a Federal suit were tangled up in the appeals process (with possibly intentional foot-dragging), would the Senate (with a clear Democratic majority from the moment the current senior class’s terms end) be able to seat the person they adjudged to have won the election? And if they did, could the Supreme Court do anything about it? It seems not, given the unambiguous language in Article 1.

Of course, none of this may be relevant. It’s still possible Peltola may reach 50% when all the votes are counted, since the ‘Bush’ votes from the Alaska backcountry would seem to be the slower ones to come in. And it’s also possible that the ranked-choice process, in which the 3rd and 4th candidates might yield more votes for Sulliven (incumbent) than for Peltola, would determine the outcome even if Peltola holds on to a lead, but under 50%. The #3 candidate is also identified on the ballot as a Republican, after all – though I understand Alaska politics are complicated and the legislature is often controlled by a bipartisan caucus rather than by a party caucus, and the current majority caucuses are made up of moderate Republicans + Democrats, with the MAGA Republicans as the minority caucus. Current analysis online suggests that Sullivan (incumbent) would pick up more votes than Peltola from Heikes and Sullivan (challenger), although perhaps not enough more to beat her current lead.