Until five Justices on the SCOTUS find that they can. The real question is this the topic that Roberts wants to go down that road. I don’t think so, but that doesn’t mean they won’t do it.
An elective despotism was not the government we fought for; but one which should not only be founded on free principles, but in which the powers of government should be so divided and balanced among several bodies of magistracy, as that no one could transcend their legal limits, without being effectually checked and restrained by the others.
I learned by trial and error that when I use Safari on my Mac I see ads after I return to the home page after selecting an article. It doesn’t happen on Firefox or Chrome. So I read TPM using Firefox and use Safari for everything else. I let the TPM Web folks know. That was back when Ad Free first came oue, but it doesn’t appear to be fixed yet.
Perhaps they thought if they followed the process the court would determine adding the citizenship question to be arbitrary, capricious, and an abuse of discretion because, well, it is.
Well, I think that Trump knows that there is no honest alternative justification, because he purpose of the question was to reduce the Hispanic population count. Full stop. So, Trump’s only real alternative play is to bully John Roberts into switching sides once the case gets back to the Supremes, which it will undoubtedly do.
If Roberts doesn’t take the bait and holds to his position, then Trump will lose again. At that point, if Trump goes forward with the question anyway, he will have committed not just a violation of the constitution, but a violation that initiates dictatorial rule in the country. Those July 4th tanks might just never leave DC.
So, Impeachment will be the only remedy left in the quiver. I say this as someone who has been opposed to Impeachment up to now. But if Trump defies the Supreme Court and puts the question on the census form, I think the House absolutely must move to impeachment, starting with Trump’s willful defying of the Court, but adding counts for each of the other outrages.
I just hope that the party that is supposedly controlled by Hollywood figures out how to stage this, the most critical political drama of our lifetime. I don’t think we are at Impeachment, yet, but we are getting closer. I think it’s time for Pelosi to make her position absolutely clear on this.
But I have to wonder, why put so much political capital into this besides just not appearing to lose? This is the republican party’s fight, not his. He’ll either be re-elected or on trial before the census makes a difference. Is he planning on campaigning on this issue, somehow claiming that the census grants voting rights to non-citizens?