SCOTUS Punts On Trump Challenge to House Subpoena Of His Financial Docs | Talking Points Memo

The Supreme Court ruled Thursday that Congress does have the authority to subpoena President Trump’s personal financial records, but in an opinion that will likely delay Congress’ ability to access those records until after the election.


This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://talkingpointsmemo.com/?p=1319215

About what I expected. They found a way to say that Oversight exists, but won’t allow it to happen to Trump before the election.

Neither ruling will result in his tax returns being read by the public before the election.

11 Likes

Only Alito and Thomas dissented.

3 Likes

Justice delayed, etc. But at least Trump’s day’s not going well, either.

14 Likes

I think the real story is that he won’t be able to get away with his (il)legal rope-a-dope bullshit if he is around for another term.

6 Likes

Whine, whine baby nobody will stop you.

2 Likes

Trump really believes he is a monarch.

8 Likes

The opinion laid out a four part test for what factors the court should weigh as they decide whether to enforce congressional subpoenas involving the President.

Judges should only make law when it suits their political purposes.

7 Likes

Addendum:

What are the chances that Trump is hiding his tax returns due to him cheating his niece and nephew out of Fred’s estate and that any Russian rubles was just an additional reason?

7 Likes

King Donald the Dope
King Donald the Deplorable
King Donald the DumbAss

1 Like

Typical narrow reading by Roberts, who depends on assorted administrative or procedural issues when writing decisions.

The House will eventually get the information.
While it would be nice if it happened before the election, the important thing is the reaffirmation by SCOTUS of the power of Congress to investigate as part of its oversight duties.

This was not a win for Trump. A temporary reprieve, at best, and the loss in the Vance case is stunningly bad for Donnie.
His meltdown over this is proof of what a horrible day he’s already having.

14 Likes

I still say the Republican establishment is laying the ground work for easing Trump’s decision to turn things over to another candidate. This is damage control from the inside out. I doubt it will work, because it’s still inside the bubble magical thinking, but there are just too many career Republicans turning on him for me to believe there isn’t something going on in the smoke-filled back rooms…

Can the lower court expedite the hearings?
Asking for a few million friends.

6 Likes

According to who? The SCOTUS? OK, so who’s going to force someone to produce those records? The DOJ?

1 Like

Whatever the lower court does, it will be appealed again to the supreme court, who very conveniently are fucking off to their summer vacation starting tomorrow and will not be back until October. They will not render any more relevant decisions until safely after the election.

15 Likes

That photo reminds me that a smile is a frown turned upside down,to only be a fly on the wall at 1600 this morning.I guess the watch word for all the walls at 1600 “INCOMING”

1 Like

The GOP establishment may want him to go, but I can’t imagine how they could force him out if he doesn’t want to go. He may be unhappy, but there is no better-protected and powerful position in the world than POTUS. Even if he loses the election, he’ll have another few months to hang on to the power and “borrowed” respect of the office.

He may even be banking on Russian interference or some outside surprise in October that gives him a win in November. He’s a gambler and will take that chance. He does have a history of walking away from failed projects, but only after they’ve completely crashed and burned. That hasn’t happened yet.

3 Likes

Well, for the Manhattan DA’s subpoena (which I think is demanding records from trumps accountants, I assume the Manhattan DA’s office serves the subpoena, to Mazars, and the NYPD would force compliance if necessary. But I am not a lawyer.

Shorter Court ruling: Trump can run out the clock but a Republican Senate can subpoena anything they want from a Biden administration.

5 Likes

Why wouldn’t he? It’s what his lawyers have been telling him and what the GOP, Federalist Society, ALEC and the rest have been trying to turn the Presidency into for decades now.

2 Likes