Reading through the tea leaves of these GOP '22 primaries, I think there is some good news for the Dems.
GOP pollsters vastly overestimated the Trumper/Qanon vote in competitive contests in OH, PA, AL and GA. Trump voters are generally regarded as Election Day voters. There was no e-day surge for Josh Mandel, Kathy Barnette, Oz, Jody Hice, David Perdue or Mo Brooks. They underperformed the polling for the most part and certainly did not experience a surge above polling estimates. The establishment candidate’s share of the vote from EV to E-Day held up reasonably well. Mo Brooks made it to a run off but this will not be a close race as he was 17 points behind Britt in Round 1, more than double the margin the polls predicted.
There are 2 reasons for this. One is that where there were competitive open primaries, a lot of Dems and Indies voted in the GOP primary against the crazy. The most stark example of this is the GA races. Brad Raffensberger, who ran well behind Kemp’s numbers in his quest to be re-elected as Secretary of State, almost certainly got over the 50% run off threshold because of Dem voters. Kemp also outperformed the polls b/c Dems and Indies voted against Perdue.
However, Dems voting in the GOP primary does not explain these big polling misses by itself. A second factor appears to be that Trump surge voters just didn’t turn out to vote. They don’t appear to be voting in large numbers. I’d like to do a deeper dive, but I suspect that the rural vote wasn’t as large a percentage of the total vote as a lot of these GOP polls had predicted.
These Trump surge voters may be checking out of politics, and there may not be as many of them as that group has experienced a high death rate due to COVID and other ailments exacerbated by the pandemic. If they’re not voting in the primary for Trump endorsed candidates, then it stands to reason that the GOP will have a tough time getting them to vote in the general election. For his part, Trump is going to have to undermine the GOP establishment candidates, because if they win, he loses and he loses the political cover needed to shield himself from prosecution.
What this suggests is that the electorate that will show up in October/November will be more educated, suburban, centrist and less ideological. An issue like abortion will cut in favor of the Dems very starkly amidst such an electorate.
I’m also sensing a more unified Dem coalition because we’ve been jolted collectively to fear what GOP rule would look like in a post-Trump era, and also because some progressive candidates are demonstrating growth and maturity and are getting broader acceptance by the party, which keeps lefties invested in the party rather than trying to tear it down or be preoccupied with internecine battles and neglecting the larger fight vs the GOP.
None of this is the CW, but the data are telling us that this electorate isn’t going to be as harshly unfriendly to the Dems like prior midterms in 1994, 2002, 2010 and 2014.