Leaked SCOTUS Draft Striking Down Roe Sets Off Firestorm

Some? How about damned near everyone…

6 Likes

Except Loving vs Virginia, because Clarance and his best friend.

12 Likes

The Interstate Commerce clause, as well as more general First Amendment presumptions about freedom of movement being subsumed into freedom of speech, would seem to allow it.

But God knows how the current SCOTUS would interpret them.

8 Likes

It’s almost like…we’re in a battle for the soul of this nation.

12 Likes

That is all there is to it, not the patriarchy, which undoubtedly exists, but it won’t be effective in trampling women’s rights without women’s collaboration.

5 Likes

Has the popular book Our Bodies, Ourselves been banned yet in Florida?

12 Likes

Of course he is. It’s a total transgression for Justice Alito to leak that draft.

18 Likes

Birth control is unlikely to be next, because too many people rely on it. Instead, I expect that it will be same sex marriage. It’s relatively recent and will appeal to the people who like to pretend that their hate is motivated by “G^d’s word”,

15 Likes

I agree. Peaceful mass movements make the news. It worked for the civil rights movement. Get the Democrats message out there.

3 Likes

The unintended consequences are more widespread poverty and ignorance, except they’re not really unintended as much as they are predictable.

21 Likes

I’m sure someone at the Heritage Foundation has been working on how to negate that whole rapists and raped woman law, along with consequences. Something titled “Death Before Dishonor” perhaps.

5 Likes

I was wondering about this too. I read that passage and I understood his argument differently. He did not claim that gay marriage, etc. were deeply rooted. He said that these other cases don’t involve the “critical moral question posed by abortion.”

Can someone explain this to me? It’s bad enough to suggest that marriage equality and freedom to engage in private consensual sex are not moral questions. (Really??). But his argument seems to be that although these cases were wrongly decided, these rights are safe because they (supposedly) don’t involve important moral questions. So his argument is that the SC only concerns itself with illegitimate decisions when what it deems “critical moral questions” are concerned?

Is this argument as incredible as it seems?

19 Likes

Get ready to be called everything but a Child of God.

4 Likes

Good God, let it!

WHITE WOMEN VOTERS!

I think they are too. Not all contraception, but anything they can argue is an abortifacient. That’s pretty much almost all of the contraception that women use. Yes, I know all the arguments about why they won’t. I simply don’t believe them.

26 Likes

My bet is on Mrs Breyer. Take that Jenny!

2 Likes

My money is on Thomas, or someone on his staff.

Thomas is the shameless movement conservative. He, or someone on his staff, is the likeliest to act out of naked political expediency.

This leak quite obviously benefits Republicans.

The decision was certain to be a bombshell when released. Leaking it now has two beneficial effects for the GOP:

  1. It diffuses the impact somewhat, by turning one big bombshell into two smaller ones (Part 1: “Relax, it’s just a draft, and it’s not here yet.” Part 2: “Relax, it’s old news, remember?”)

  2. It moves much of the impact away from the election.

Basically: the decision was a bomb. And they took 2/3 of the bomb and moved it to a much safer location to set it off.

I don’t know why everyone’s jumping to the conclusion that one of the liberals leaked this. They’re simply not giving any thought to who benefits from the leak.

13 Likes

I get called all kind of things here, kinda used to.

4 Likes

What if being pregnant in a state that has banned abortion means, in effect, you are bound by that state’s laws to give birth? Now, there are areas of the law wherein what you are bound by law to do in one state binds you in others. For instance, if you have your driver license revoked for life in Ohio for multiple DUIs you can’t go to Illinois and just get a license there. Your conduct in Ohio has resulted in restricting your options to drive everywhere. I can see abortion, or your legal duty to give birth by virtue of your state citizenship, governing your options to go elsewhere for that abortion.

5 Likes

I think SSM is safe simply because it would be one of the most epic legal/procedural clusterfucks in history to try to undo it. What we’re likely to see next is shitloads of Free Exercise exceptions from anti-discrimination laws.

16 Likes

Insurrection? So pro-choice protestors are gonna overthrow the Democratic administration? I know she’s stupid and her audience is dumber yet, but shouldn’t she do at least slightly better than that?

11 Likes