JD Vance's 'Purpose'

His book on the Rothschilds was good. The big financial history one that followed, good also. The British empire one,…
He started to go downhill once he started getting TV bookings.

4 Likes

Sorry, but this theory is the dumbest idea I have heard in a while.

We’re only barely living past 35 years in the last evolutionary phase.

My belief that universities turn out acolytes and little else goes on undiminished.

4 Likes

“Natural Law” is inherently teleological.

22 Likes

Obsessing about kids’ genitalia on the track field, or who uses the school bathroom is weird as fuck.

41 Likes

Another example of Goopers lacking self-awareness: JV labeling Democratic statements against him and the felon as “bullying” and “schoolyard attacks.”

JV also needs to shut up about reproduction, and women in general, because it’s obvious he knows NOTHING about either.

32 Likes

May we steal “shillbilly”?

16 Likes

In the world of American Conservatism he is by definition more of an expert than any woman because he’s a man.

29 Likes

The scientific hypothesis is one thing

Weird JD Vance using it to argue that older women are of value only because they are available to babysit the grandchildren is another.

It’s as though we were to demand that JD stop running around and go home and the finish raising his kids. His highest purpose is to take care of them and anything else that he wishes to do has to
take second place.

Which, by the way, is what he has demanded from his wife.

34 Likes

End run around FARA.

13 Likes

I fully agree that Vance is an authortarian creep… just as trump is.
I just reacted to his use of the term “menopause” as if he, with his background in venture capitalism, is some sort of expert in a field he knows nothing about (that’s also a trump trait).

25 Likes

Well, if we engage in a utilitarian teleology for a minute, JV Dance’s purpose, as evidenced by the way his face looks, is to be punched in said face.

23 Likes

As a Scotsman myself, his twisting of history to suit the anti-Independence movement was the final straw. I’m afraid I’d have to put his lights out.

I am not sure on the study of history even. I think it is manhandled into the purposes of a social vanity. Ferguson is a propped up shill for the controlling class.

During the 1700s the entire Scottish culture was erased. Exterminated in a way that Native American culture was not. Burns is literally all that’s left of the original Scots language.

History mentions it not at all.

20 Likes

Born and raised in Missouri (st Louis area) and thought Texas, where I live now, had become the armpit of America wrt politics but I’m discovering it’s a wash. Probably cheaper to live there though. lol

11 Likes

The article is premised on the idea that he misuses the grandmother hypothesis to make an authoritarian point.

The grandmother hypothesis may explain some aspects of human evolutionary biology that are at odds with other animals. That evolutionary advantage is not a purpose, he is trying to imply intent.

38 Likes

The irony is, the fact women live past fertility leads to the uncomfortable (for right-wing Christians and misogynists) that women are not slaves to eternally pumping out kids. That, and this may be shocking, women can (and should) do whatever the fuck they want.

53 Likes

“To prevent Fara registration, …the legal advisers suggested channeling funds through a third-party American nonprofit.”

It must be okay. It’s channeling.

Not laundering  ; - )

18 Likes

Being an expert in all things is the sole province of Supreme Court Justices, recently exemplified by their decision to place their judgment ahead of the professionals who staff the administrative agencies.

33 Likes

Pretty sure it was simply describing the kleptomaniacal picking over the remains of the Soviet state post collapse. Where it was a fairly lawless looting of the Soviet state leading to the rise of oligarchs, and into a dictatorship.

10 Likes

Some scientists think only the human species has evolved a “menopause” and then can survive for years of decades after. However toothed whales (think killer whales for one but there are others) undergo menopause. Many kinds of mammals, if they can outlive the ovary’s production of egg cells and go through the consequent hormonal changes can be thought of as “post menopausal”

29 Likes

Given that just a couple of centuries ago human life expectancy was approximately 40 years, I think that hypothesis is crap.

And I don’t recall Butter Boy saying anything about evolutionary biology (his supporters aren’t big believers in that sciency stuff).

22 Likes