If Trump Triggered A Doomsday Election Scenario, Would President Pelosi Come To The Rescue?

I am not going to unsee this now. Undo it! Undo it!

1 Like

Both Trump and Pence, due to their failure to properly social distance, get Covid and die. If there actually was a God I’m sure that’s what would happen.

3 Likes

Or Clinton (Hillary), just for the head asplodey.

7 Likes

A certain racehorse would beg to differ.

2 Likes

If u lost ur Republic /it’s dead in Senate JUST DISCOVERED here r identifiers Left wing Blue 2020//SHE ///RIHGT WING NAZI ARMBAND NO PRINTED INFO. Sorry for bad news

1 Like

Amazon will need a whole new section of this fanfic stuff, as there is SOOO much material: the Marshal of the Supreme Court perp walking Scumbag; Bob Mueller and his crack team of untouchables perp walking the Scumbag; the Tower of the House of Representatives brimming with jailed subpoena defiers, the SDNY perp walking the Scumbag. The list of fantasy goes on and on and on and on.

3 Likes

what evidence do we have that they won’t?

11 Likes

Interesting.

That wording in the 20th Amendment applies only when a President and Vice President have failed to qualify, so the “officer” requirement from Article II still applies in cases of death, removal, or resignation.

On the other hand, I think the “officer” argument is a bit weak. Article I Section 2 says:

The House of Representatives shall chuse their Speaker and other Officers; and shall have the sole Power of Impeachment.

So the Speaker of the House is an Officer.

One might argue that the Speaker is only an officer of the House, but that’s a tougher argument to make.

5 Likes

Better poli-sci fantasy:

  • Biden wins in a landslide that only the worst Adderall-riddled morons can’t see on election night.
  • Democrats pick up 5-6 seats in the Senate (because Rs didn’t respect the will of the people)
  • Clarence Thomas gets Covid-19 and says hi to Herman Cain
  • Brett the Rapist gets impeached and convicted for lying during his confirmation
  • Biden nominates two non-ACA-killing judges to the SCOTUS
  • The Senate expands the SCOTUS to 11 seats
  • Biden nominates two more judges
  • The mirror trading scandal hits and 20-60 Rs are caught in its web and go to jail because under Biden, we’ll actually have a FEC, FBI, and DOJ
  • Trump gets to wear an outfit that matches his spray-on for what little is left of his mini-stroking life
  • Bill Barr is investigated and convicted of obstruction of justice, gets cell next to Donnie so he can listen to him whine about how badly Bill messed up
30 Likes

I think it’s in part an artifact of English Common Law, which places a lot of political power on “precedent” rather than relying on statutory laws for everything. That has benefits in that it provides latitude to adjust to changing circumstances without necessarily rewriting conflicting laws in their entirety, but it also falls prey to bad actors who abuse the norms.

The alternative Statutory Law tradition requires every legal issue has to be written in a statute before it can be adjudicated, which leads to very byzantine law codes (more so than our Common Law) and it’s less quick to adjust when things change. It is more resilient to norm-busting, but as stated, also less maneuverable for changes in norms and expectations of the citizenry.

6 Likes

I love this. The thing is that it isn’t far-fetched really. It’s the way things should happen.

5 Likes

“This ship cannot sink!” (Titanic)

“No one will ever Bomb Berlin!” (Goering) (not Matt)

and one of my favorites:

16 Likes

The expanded SCOTUS is optional. Brett getting convicted is the least realistic part.

Do we have any people known to be infectious that can give Clarence and Brett free hugs?

1 Like

Ya, you betcha.

1 Like

Under Scenario #1:

Every state delegation in the House would get one vote for the top three presidential candidates — presumably Joe Biden, Donald Trump and the third party candidate who accrued the most votes.

The House would vote for one of the top three by electoral votes. It would be just Biden and Trump unless some third party candidate wins a state, or D.C., or one of the districts of Maine or Nebraska. That seems unlikely this year. But faithless electors could also create such a scenario.

On the other hand, a third party candidate winning one or more electoral votes would make it more likely that neither Biden nor Trump gets a majority. If a candidate has a plurality but not a majority, it still goes to the House. (Which raises questions for a popular vote system if we manage to get rid of the Electoral College.)

Another fun fact: The House and Senate don’t have to agree. In principle we could end up with Biden/Pence or Trump/Harris.

3 Likes

Actually, either spelling is acceptable, and it’s only been fairly recently that “forgo” has become the favored spelling in American English.

6 Likes

The state of Louisiana operates solely by statute - the Napoleonic Code. IF you aren’t aware, Louisiana is one of the most corrupt states in the country.

We aren’t strictly Common Law - we are a mixture of Statute and Court precedent.

6 Likes

It’s also worth noting just how necessary “Democratic Myths” are.

6 Likes

And how unnecessary the Electoral College is.

6 Likes

Makes sense since they started as a French colony rather than most states which began as English colonies or American territories (or were taken from Spain/Mexico by the US much later on).

5 Likes