GOP WI Justice Invokes Japanese Internment In Oral Arguments

…and another example of ‘politics’. Nobody wants the job so the mediocre RISE. It looks like Wisconsin’s judges are about as ‘competent’ as Texas ones.

7 Likes

Soooo,when are we gonna kick her out of her house and sell it to someone else?

15 Likes

Sure. Except for that rounding them up, barbed wire, armed guard, seizing the property (and not returning it) kind of thing. Otherwise, just like it. JFC did these people take a basic American history course?

30 Likes

It’s a good thing that Bob La Follette is already dead – what Wisconsin has become would surely kill him.

22 Likes

“Could the Secretary, under this broad delegation of legislative or legislative-like power, order people out of their homes and into centers where they’d be properly socially distanced in order to combat the pandemic?” she asked.

I gather she asked from the safey of her own home on this electronic hearing.
So, she’s so concerned about the injustice of this order that she’s inflicting its limitations on herself.
Moreover, it seems safe to suppose that she would fight any effort to have to hear this challenge in person, in an open court.
Which, I suppose, speaks volumes about the source of her ‘concerns.’

13 Likes

The judge wants to know how an Equal Protection case applies to a pandemic.

Words fail.

18 Likes

Maybe the brave Wisconsinite who filed this lawsuit should put her money where her mouth is. Go ahead and go to church once the order is lifted and proceed directly to a hospital caring for Covid patients. The facility might be looking for a few good volunteers.

18 Likes

Well, at least she didn’t analogize with Nazis or Stalinists.

6 Likes

I’m stealing this.

7 Likes

Try to explain this to the judge. Like talking to a 14-yr old who might make such an analogy, But a 14-yr old can be excused.

6 Likes

What a ridiculous argument.

The decision to inter the Japanese-Americans was based solely upon rank racism, not upon any evidence or science. Whereas the War in Europe was an ideological war, the War in the Pacific was a race war, and it was never, ever, denied being such. The fight against the Nazis was a fight to protect Democracy from Dictatorship. The fight against the Japanese was a war by White, Christian America against the “inscrutable, Emperor-worshiping Japanese.” Anyone who LOOKED like “The Enemy” was immediately suspect.

The US Government did not round up Americans of German, or Italian descent, just the Japanese-Americans. If they had, there would have been no one left to fight WW2.

The Japanese-Americans on the west coast were a convenient scapegoat for America (and the Grifters who stole their businesses and land because of the interments.)
It is also interesting that in Hawaii, there was NO roundup of Japanese-descendants, because almost 1/3 of the island is of Japanese descent and they could not afford the resulting drop in workers.

28 Likes

The “conservative” “justices” on the WI supreme court are not smart enough to work traffic court. They are not conservative, they are fascist/reactionary, and justice is not part of their tool kit.

Having grown up with great respect for actual conservative justices (see Harlan, both ones…), and had some of the Smart Reagan ones grown on me (see Posner, and hell even Easterbook at times) really sad to see what “conservatism” has become.

14 Likes

Grew up in next door Chicago. Fighting Bob was still a hero long after he died.

10 Likes

OT: A little picker upper -his poll numbers are droppping. It seems incremental but every percentage point down is a bonus.

18 Likes

As long as your choice might take a few others down with you.
It’s kind of the Jonestown version of the right.

10 Likes

What thrills the Death Cult is that they are indirectly causing the death of inferiors. “Elderly people? Ewww. Smelly and gross. Latinx people in service jobs having to go to work? Talk English why don’t they! Doctors and nurses? High and mighty, thinking they’re so smart! And so on. “There’s always a new flu going around.” Mostly icky people will get it, because it’s God culling the herd. And so on… Local commenter wrote “1% will get it and 1% of those will die and it won’t be me so stop keeping me a prisoner.” Magical evangelical prosperity-gospel reasoning.

17 Likes

Wonder how we’ll ever get good, much less great justices these days.
These GOP picks give mediocrity a bad name.

7 Likes

Why do we have such a long time between an election and the winner assuming office? Most other countries just install the winner within a day or two. And it’s not like Supreme Court Justice in Wisconsin requires a transition.

6 Likes

In any sane world he’d be at 25%. He’s basically regressed to his mean which is where he’ll stay.

12 Likes

Pukes need to win more Darwin Awards. Simple

1 Like