Discussion: Top Saudi Education Official Fired After Yoda Shows Up In History Textbook

6 Likes

I donā€™t know who Betsey will be quicker to hireā€“the guy who got fired(incompetent) or the guy who fired him(fanatical). Theyā€™ll both fit in.
"Everyone loves King Faisal here, even the younger generations,ā€ he said.
Iā€™m sure any Saudi citizen who didnā€™t love King Faisal would immediately tell everybody. The rulers there are always open to constructive input.

7 Likes

When the thread-winning comment is also the lede, our work here is done.

Well played, Esme!

27 Likes

This is why you never use placeholder images or text. They get published.

17 Likes

Placing this image in a history textbook in Alabama gets you elected to the U.S. Senate.

27 Likes

Ixnay. Jeebus isnā€™t carrying.

20 Likes

Classic.

At least it was either a mistake or a joke that was meant to be corrected. Unlike some things that have been finding their way into US history text books which are intentional fabrications, omissions, or fabrications in recent years. https://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/06/us/publisher-promises-revisions-after-textbook-refers-to-african-slaves-as-workers.html

8 Likes

Ahmed Al-Issa also fired ā€œothers responsible for the mishap who reviewed and approvedā€ the image.

Several conspirators were arrested in early morning raids, and Yoda was later publicly lashed and beheaded.

20 Likes

Proofread or do not, there is no try.

Ms. Cribb, I have no particular beef with your articles, but TPM in general might be humble when thinking about criticizing anyone for a lack of proofreading.

3 Likes

Photoshopping various fictional cultural icons into famous historical scenes is so childish. Itā€™s important that kids get an unbiased, unvarnished view of history and historical events.

Thatā€™s why the Texas Board of Education has begun a month-long project to both shorten and refocus history so we can affirmatively answer that rarely asked question first posed by George W. Bush: ā€œIs our children learning?ā€

Gone will be the use of mere words, historical documents and boring accounts, replaced with an emphasis on pictures that depict history the way we want them to know it.

For instance, below is the complete chapter on Englandā€™s Queen Elizabeth I. Gone are the boring facts and events of the Elizabethan Era, replaced by a single photo.

We are truly on the cusp of an enlightened era. Thank you, Texas.

8 Likes

Q: Who is the most important person in the publishing company?

A: The preefrooder.

13 Likes

ā€¦and Trump can only DREAM to be this ā€˜powerfulā€™ā€¦

2 Likes

Couldnā€™t they just cover it over with something ā€¦ even temp. like ā€¦

For when the next Boss changes his mind ? ? ā€¦

5 Likes

Aw, come on, Iā€™m usually with you on that point, but that was an awesome lead. Fire away, Ms. Cribb!

9 Likes

You mean Republicans work in the education department in Saudi Arabia, too?

1 Like

4 Likes

Okay, dudeā€¦ enough. The shift key on my keyboard is now a little ā€œiffyā€, and I believe thatā€™s a direct result of, (and I am in consultation with an attorney about this), reading one of your posts while consuming a cold, carbonated beverage. Your posts need a reader advisory: ā€œChoking/Spraying Hazard Finish all foods and beverages before readingā€

4 Likes

Edit this textbook, you will

1 Like

Used to be, school kids did a fine job of ā€œannotatingā€ history books. You should have seen the state history textbook I had to use, one that had been issued a couple of decades previously. The ā€œEverybody must wear a Hitler moustache!ā€ cadre had gotten to pretty much every picture in every one of those books at one point or another.

Nowadays though textbooks have gone electronic. Kids at my sonā€™s school have a chromebook and all their texts are online. To be fair none of his classes have ever asked kids to lug their own copy around; they kept them at home and used a class set at school. They literally have no locker time between classes anyway.

I suppose electronic books can be kept up-to-date and undefaced. On the other hand, control of content is centralized and that comes with its own dangers. Luckily most of my kids teachers havenā€™t used textbooks all that much anyway.

4 Likes

From the National Gallery in London. I canā€™t remember who it is supposed to be, but I suspect that itā€™s really a caricature of Blair slipped in to see if anyone would notice.

2 Likes