Discussion: South Dakota Newspaper Editor Wants Nothing To Do With Lawmaker's Crazy Obama-ISIL Joke

Discussion for article #228500

ā€œI hope maybe you can update your piece to indicate that, since as
editor, I would never approve such a column,ā€ Pfankuch told TPM in the email.

Now his PUBLISHER, on the other hand, would approve it in a New York Minute
.

2 Likes

I’m confused. The guy says it would never pass muster in his newspaper but he has no problem with it appearing on their website? WTF kind of weasel words are those? And then he adds that he’s open to a column by her on arming teachers? This editor talks out of both sides of his mouth. Pfft!

3 Likes

Well…

ā€œWe’re actually talking now about whether to do a piece for the daily on a lawmaker who says such things,ā€ he wrote. ā€œShe’s been out there in a lot of things…but this is a Whaaaaa? moment I don’t think we can ignore.ā€

I’ll forgive him if he follows thru on the above.

5 Likes

Welcome to the Wonderful World of Gannett newspapers!

3 Likes

Dude’s name is basically ā€œpancakeā€ (shortened version I’m guessing). Story just hit plaid speed.

2 Likes

I live in SD, in Sioux Falls. Sioux Falls is in the ā€œliberalā€ eastern part of the state. The western part of the state, ā€œwest-riverā€, is filled with insane wacks. One person running in 2012 used the slogan ā€œStop socialism in South Dakotaā€. Now, for those of you nodding in agreement, there is absolutely none of the dreaded S-word in South Dakota. The west-river wacks are nuts. Most areas out there don’t even get democrats to run against the Republicans.

5 Likes

What’s the ratio of Native Americans there?

This must be common. I note our local suburban daily allows – yea, encourages and publishes the most outrageous anti-Obama, anti-Dem letters and columns shamelessly, then wonders why circulation keeps falling.

1 Like

This is like her Sharon Angle moment, ā€˜2nd amendment remedies’ for her.

The state of SD has about 900,000 residents, and possibly 100,000 Indians. There are 9 reservations (Pine Ridge, Rosebud, probably the best known). I myself work in a group that has a large Indian section, and we do research with the Indian tribes (parenthetical note: I asked one of the Indians what the term to use is, and he said ā€œIndianā€; I would imagine that YMMV). In SD, Democrats do well when the Indian vote is strong, and do poorly when the Indian vote is weak.

In the city of Sioux Falls itself, there are a fair number of Indians. But the res populations are high.

1 Like

The amount of hot air produced by stupid white people is an inexhaustible natural resource that we need to take advantage of. If we harnessed such stupidity intelligently, we could solve our energy problems overnight.

2 Likes

** I think the score was Harding County 36 to 18 over Hill City.

A second American journalist, Steven Sotloff, was beheaded by ISIS this week**

And these are exactly the sorts of issues a state politician should be given a megaphone to address.

Because a football score is exactly like an international issue.

Also? Because a continuing virulent nuttiness that connects every awful thing to that black guy in the White House is also accepted and goes without saying.

SSDD

1 Like

My local giveaway fishwrap, The San Mateo Daily Journal, is a mere cog in a corporate-owned multistate network of papers that each puts on the pretense of being ā€œlocally-owned and operatedā€ and ā€œtotally independent.ā€

As you might imagine, they publish letters from astroturfing nutters (of the ā€œjust asking questionsā€ variety) with regular frequency (a frequency in clear violation of their own printed policies), and print liberal debunking distinctly less often for appearances. Every headline about Obama is written to make him seem desperate and weak, or overreaching. There was a period where the low-rent comics section ran Mallard Fillmore, then Day by Day, then Prickly City, finally giving up after the incredibly racist State of the Union flashed in its pan.

It exists to keep the elderly and poorly-educated scared and voting Republican. (I continue to pick up a copy only to kill some time with the Sudoku and KenKen.)

Yes, you are.

Pfankuch also said that Olson, who led the post-Sandy Hook effort to arm teachers in South Dakota, might end up inspiring a piece in the Journal.

"We’re actually talking now about whether to do a piece for the daily on a lawmaker who says such things," he wrote. 

A column written ā€œonā€ a person is significantly different from a column written ā€œbyā€ that same person.

Just thought you should know.

1 Like

My mistake…In my reading I got my preposition wrong. Still doesn’t explain why he pretends the paper’s website reporting is somehow unattached from his paper.

That’s okay. The article wasn’t very clearly written, but then it’s by Tom Kludt so not unexpected.

On the other, my guess would be that he doesn’t have editorial control over the website, just the print edition. As I say, that’s just a guess, but often things appear on a website that would never make it into print because of different management structures.

1 Like