Discussion: Rep. John Lewis Hospitalized, Under 'Routine Observation'

The man is a giant in an institution full of one-celled parasites.

Nothing but the best of recoveries for you, Rep. Lewis.

28 Likes

How not to present your medical issues to the public.

Lewis has zero obligation to make any public statements whatsoever about his health.

That said, it is certainly true, that if health concerns result in a hospitalization, if you are a public figure like Lewis, word is likely to get out anyway, so you at least have to announce the fact of the hospitalization. Beyond that, perhaps in some sense you are at least under some pressure to talk about why you were hospitalized. But if you decide to do that, offer an explanation rather than stand on your right to privacy, it makes no sense to offer an explanation that explains nothing.

People don’t get admitted to hospitals for observation as any sort of routine, not for decades now, and not really ever. It’s not uncommon to be admitted for observation for concerns that don’t pan out, but such concerns would not be over any routine matter, but would be concern over a heart rhythm problem, or of an impending myocardial infarction or of a possible stroke, etc. ,etc.

Nothing in the list of things that get you admitted for observation is the least bit routine or at all trivial. That is not some bit of arcane and obscure medical knowledge, but the common experience of millions of members of the general public. These millions are also perfectly familiar with the concept that hospitalized observation for concern over very serious health problems often results in that concern being refuted during the hospitalization. Admitting that someone was hospitalized for observation because he had chest pain is not at all going to be mistaken by any members of the general public who have any goodwill towards Lewis for an admission that he had a heart attack. Failing to say what the illness on the plane was that caused the concern is only going to leave people who do not have good will towards Lewis free to fill in the obvious blank with whatever uncharitable speculation they care to insert.

If you do decide to abandon your right to say not a goddamn thing about your health problems, if you decide to go beyond just an announcement of what the public will find out anyway, that you’ve been admitted to the hospital, you should say something informative. Otherwise keep silence, where silence is your perfect right. “Hospitalized for routine observation” is just BS, and Lewis deserves better.

What happens if he has to leave office? Evil GA governor get to appoint?

Get well soon, Rep Lewis.

No need to leave office.
McCain is not leaving. Strom Thurmond was stuffed and propped up in a chair for years.

We need Rep Lewis’ political and moral leadership - he needs to stay.

1 Like

Please stay well, Mr. Lewis!!! I am a lot younger than Reps. Lewis and Pelosi, and even Hillary. I watch in awe as these “elderly” folks continue to have the incredible energy it takes to do what they do. If I am ever presented with the need to gear up and be tough like that for the good of my country, I will contact RBG’s trainer. The need to survive this maladministration is a tremendous elixir.

All of the forces of good are with you, Congressman Lewis.

Hoping for a speedy recovery. John Lewis is a national treasure.