Discussion: READ: Judge Smacks Down Trump Bid To Halt House Subpoena To Accountant

Mehta denied the request for a stay pending appeal. They can appeal until they’re blue in the face, but the accountants have to cough up.

16 Likes

Hooray!!!

Ok, now someone take his phone away before we’re at war w/Iran…

22 Likes

Damn. I could use some good news. I hope the courts run over Trump, with a satisfying crunch, like a steamroller over a large fat stink beetle.

56 Likes

The Honorable Amit Mehta writes with such lucidity.

19 Likes

Now is when the rubber meets the road. Trump will have to appeal to the CTA, and ask for a stay. If that is denied, the documents get produced.

4 Likes

I am not sure that I agree with Mariotti here but it is a step in favor of the Constitution

39 Likes

Emergency, emergency, just like the border wall.

15 Likes

:joy:

15 Likes

what I found telling was how he framed the quote, to wit:

But he objected to the Covode Committee’s investigation of his conduct. He maintained that the
House of Representatives possessed no general powers to investigate him, except when sitting as
> an impeaching body

16 Likes

A stink beetle. ooooh Ima gonna steal that…

3 Likes

It’s not up to Trump to ignore the decision — Mazars is the one with the documents and the subject of the subpoena. They will turn over the docs ASAP unless Trump gets a Court of Appeals Judge to issue an emergency stay of the District Court’s order and a temporary restraining order preventing the document production.

ETA: I’m assuming Cummings doesn’t voluntarily suspend enforcement of the subpoena pending appeal, as he did pending this ruling. That would be taking comity too far.

21 Likes
100 Likes

not quite.

Trump can (and I’m sure, is at this very moment) requesting an emergency stay from a judge in the Court of Appeals…

2 Likes

I am not a lawyer, but I am a historian with a keen interest in public opinion.

Trump has elated and invigorated people who wish for vengeance on the 21 Century, its demography and its women.

Those of us who oppose Trump have had little respite since 2015. It has been a beat-down by a sociopath.

Any…and I mean

#ANY

element of movement our way has to be nurtured and built upon

54 Likes

Who has stated he will recuse himself from at least some matters Trump. ETA: recusal was limited to kavanaugh ethics hearing.

6 Likes

[quote=“leftcoaster, post:32, topic:88112”]
I wonder who the chief judge is in the circuit where all of the fights between Congress and Trump will play out and whether he cares about partisan norm-busting. Oh that’s right…it’s some guy named Merrick Garland.

2:06 PM- 20 May 2019

Great…

12 Likes

Wow, this Judge is blistering.

67 Likes

Good. Make them sweat

6 Likes

Not being a lawyer, but could Judge Mehta be thinking beyond this particular case? It’s appears that he’s illuminating a way forward.

27 Likes

This has been my position. Requiring the Congress to begin a formal impeachment inquiry before allowing ANY investigation encroaches on the Congress’s constitutionally prescribed right to determine its own process under Article 1, Sec 5.

31 Likes