Discussion: Agent, Operative, Plant, Spy? What To Call Mariia Butina

Pretty sure this guy was a character in one of the Harry Potter movies.

2 Likes

OT. The UK authorities now know how the poisoned couple came to be exposed to the Novichok

The man who found the bottle of the nerve agent Novichok which killed his partner said it was in a glass bottle within an “expensive-looking” box.
Charlie Rowley, who was also poisoned, said he gave his partner Dawn Sturgess the box - which he believed to be perfume - as a present.

He described the bottle as having a plastic dispenser which was held in a cardboard box with a plastic moulding.
He said it looked expensive and that Ms Sturgess recognised the brand on the box.
In an interview with ITV News, he said: "I do have a memory of her spraying it on her wrists and rubbing them together.
"I guess that’s how she applied it and became ill. I guess how I got in contact with it is when I put the spray part to the bottle… I ended tipping some on my hands, but I washed it off under the tap.

Explains why she died and he survived. So it was smuggled in to the UK in an atomizer made to look like perfume or cologne.

9 Likes

How about just…guilty?

One complicating factor here is that just as the U.S. has a uniquely constrained definition of “treason,” it also has a narrower definition of “espionage.” For whatever reason, we define “espionage” in terms of stealing military secrets or “defense information.” It’s also a crime to steal or knowingly communicate classified information, but that isn’t really “espionage” under our law. In practice, this has resulted in “defense information” being interpreted rather broadly, but there it is.

She seems likely to have broken a bunch of laws, but none of them really count as “spying” under our law but very much would in most other countries.

(Espionage Act, as revised, here for those interested)

https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/part-I/chapter-37

5 Likes

Mariya Putaina…

1 Like

What To Call Mariia Butina?

Easy, she was a businesswomen who collaborated with the Republican party, the NRA and Russia to defraud the United States.

Agent, operative, plant, spy? No, those all give her the benefit of the doubt in being an anomoly in the Republican gun-rights movement, when she and her actions were part and parcel.

2 Likes

“Russian skank” works well for me.

5 Likes

A spy is here to “spy” on you…see what you are up to. That’s not what Butina was up to. She wasn’t here to see what we are doing as much as she was here trying to get us to do something.

This is one issue that needs the “analysis” around it shit canned so we can all see the obvious. Putin wanted Trump elected becuse he thought him pliable enough to get the Magnitsky act sanctions lifted. That is what this is about. Not better relations or any of the other shit being tossed about. Putin thought Trump stupid enough to undo the sanctions Obama set in place. One, because Trump is stupid and Two because Trump suffers an enormous inferiority complex when it comes to Obama. Nuff said.

Russia launched a multi-pronged effort to get that done. The hacking, the election meddling from mother Russia but some of the plan had to go down face to face in the USA. Money…it’s what elections in America are about. Putin knows that. So send a pretty girl to the USA on a student visa and set her to task. That task…get the NRA to take Russian money to help elect Trump. That’s it folks. Nothing more. Not a spy. A financial criminal and immigrant law breaker.

2 Likes

“I just met a spy named Mariia . . .”

Really dude, you repaired your glasses frame with a band-aid and showed up on TV wearing them?

Did Butina break them with her Onatop thigh lock?

1 Like

1 Like

:joy:

1 Like

You can point to her lack of tradecraft and clumsy ways and say she was a bumbling freelancer, but the great patriots in the Republican leadership and the NRA ate it all up. The great patriots took the Russian money and the Russians gained influence. She was precisely what was needed to secure the influence Putin wanted.

No I think downplaying Mariia Butina and her impact does a disservice to all of us. It sets the stage for the great patriots to quietly walk away from responsibility for their lack of patriotism.

3 Likes

“Her tradecraft, her basic operational security was sufficiently amateurish that she does not strike me as someone who has been trained,”

Meaning she was more than a match for the NRA and GOP.

It doesn’t take a lot of training to be dangerous, just look at any 5-year-old who gets their daddy’s loaded gun.

3 Likes

In that outfit? Oscar Wilde?

That photo is disgusting. I don’t care what the animals did.

1 Like

Melania?

I know what to call her:

Outta here.

And into a Federal Women’s Prison…

My apologies for stealing your thunder.